Pittsburgh Steelers Cookies
39 comments » 
It’s football season, folks! Today starts the NFL’s Kickoff Weekend, which begins with a night game featuring none other than the Super Bowl Champion Pittsburgh Steelers hosting the Tennessee Titans. Since I already threw Pittsburgh Penguins decorated sugar cookies at you during the Stanley Cup playoffs, I figured I couldn’t play favorites and needed create Steelers cookies for the start of the season. After the Super Bowl last year I bought a Pfaltzgraff Pittsburgh Steelers cookie mold (I bought it on eBay but can’t find it on there any longer) and used it to create these cookies.
The cookies are decorated with royal icing and the word “Steelers” was imprinted with black fondant. If you are new to cookie decorating, you may want to check out the tutorial I did on how to decorate cookies with royal icing. Since the mold was very easy to press the fondant into, I am thinking about trying a version of the cookie decorated with fondant for a smoother look. But then again, sugar cookies were MADE for icing! In any case, enjoy, and best of luck to your team, unless they play the Steelers this season! 
HERE WE GO STEELERS, HERE WE GO!
[I'm off gallivanting in southern Florida with my Chief Culinary Consultant this week, but have cooked up enough in the Brown Eyed Baker kitchen to keep you drooling while I'm gone. Comment and email replies will be slow, if at all, but I'll be back on Monday the 14th and will catch up on comments and questions as quickly as possible.]
I love how you’ve got that Steelers imprint there. Off to your post on decorating with royal icing.
Reply
OH MY GOD I NEED THAT MOLD! This might be a dire emergency. Seriously. I just make Steelers cupcakes for every game… but molded COOKIES?!? How did I not know about this?!?!!?!
Reply
This is amazing! Thanks for sharing
Reply
Here we go Steelers, here we go!
Reply
I used your recipe and the tutorial for royal icing for my mom’s 50th birthday party and the cookies turned out amazing. They were a hit and were easy to do with your instructions.
Thanks!
Reply
I would love these except for the fact that they are Steelers
Go Dolphins!
Honestly, though these are really cute!
Reply
Very cool. Now…Dallas Cowboys cookies…anytime soon?
Reply
Those are SO cool!!!!!
Reply
Those are beautiful!!!!
Reply
Very cool! They look great!
Reply
Cute! But I have to say it…Go Titans!:)
Reply
haha WOW that is some serious team dedication!
Reply
Amazing! I love it..
Reply
how cool are those! now if you could just find a Cowboy one for me
Reply
Wow great job on the cookies! I had no idea they had cookie cutters for sports teams. That’s awesome. I love how you pressed “steelers” out in fondant.
Reply
How fun. I’ll have to try this on some cupcakes as well.
Reply
Love your team spirit!
Reply
These are so cute – I absolutely love them! As a lifelong Steelers fan, I think this is the sweetest black and gold treat I’ve seen.
Reply
Cool! Pittsburgh fans would be so proud. Great job. Tremendous patience:)
Reply
Since I live in the Philippines and they don’t show much of football games, I don’t really have a team. But I love watching football once in a while. Those cookies are really cute and awesome.
Reply
Look at how creative you are! These are cute.
Reply
We do love our football in Australia (although our season is just ending), but I have never seen anything like these moulds! A great idea as it is another opportunity to enjoy cookies!
Reply
That’s quite a decoration!
Reply
I had no clue Pfaltzgraff had a Steelers mold. My sister and bro-in-law would be over the moon. Gotta get my hands on one of those.
Your cookies look awesome.
Reply
ahhh..i need that mold too and i can’t seem to find anything even similar to it. if anyone finds it please please please please please let me know!!!!
Reply
These look amazing. Go Steelers!!
Reply
just bought mold on ebay. hurry only 2 left! now off to the icing tutorial. Thank you!
Reply
Woohoo! Love these babies!
Reply
Your cookies look great! For those of you that don’t have a mold or the time to decorate in such detail, check out my new business – CookieToppers.com. I have edible cookie decorations for the Steeler Fans here in Pittsburgh. They are so easy to use, just use a cookie cutter for your cookie shapes, then ice your cookie, then lay my cookie topper on to the cookie. It is so easy. I have Steeler Jersey Cookie Toppers and much more.
Reply
Hey. I got a 502 gateway error earlier today when I tried to access this page. Anyone else had the problem?
Reply
Pingback: Pittsburgh Steelers Football Jersey Cookies | Brown Eyed Baker
Does anyone know where I can get that Steelers mold???
Reply
Michelle on February 15th, 2011 at 9:25 pm
Hi Chris, I got it on eBay a couple of years ago, but haven’t seen it anywhere since
Reply
Pingback: Cookies for the Super Bowl | Super Bowl Recipes | Brown Eyed Baker
I just started working for a company that makes cookie cutters…. wondered if you had ever seen all the shapes they offer. Your cookies are great! I sent this Steelers design to my neighbor.
Reply
Pingback: 45 Super Bowl Recipes for Super Bowl XLV | Brown Eyed Baker
I just came across your website via google looking for a great sugar cookie icing tips & now I see youre a pittsburgh fan! Just made my night! I cant wait to try out your tips!
Reply
These are AWESOME! I would love to make ones like this of the Falcons!
Reply
Pingback: Baklava Recipe