Peanut Butter Buckeyes Recipe
This classic Buckeyes Recipe is a family favorite; peanut butter balls dipped in chocolate only require a few ingredients and are a holiday staple. No Christmas cookie tray is complete unless it is overflowing with peanut butter buckeyes!
I absolutely love Christmas baking, and for my entire life my very favorite Christmas recipes involve the combination of chocolate and peanut butter, namely peanut butter blossoms and these peanut butter buckeyes. I’ve adored them ever since I was a kid; how could you not love something that is basically a homemade version of Reese’s peanut butter cups?
These sweet peanut butter balls dipped in chocolate are so easy to make and the recipe yields a TON, the combination of which makes them absolutely perfect for holiday baking.
How to Make Buckeyes
I have been making this buckeyes recipe for as long as I can remember; it comes from my dad’s cousin, and it has been gracing our holiday dessert trays since I was a baby. The recipe is super simple, only requires a handful of ingredients, and you do not need any special equipment. Here’s what you do!
First, use a wooden spoon to stir together softened butter, peanut butter, salt, vanilla extract, and powdered sugar. You can bust out a stand or hand mixer if you want, but it’s just as easily accomplished with a plain ‘ol wooden spoon. This filling tastes so much like a legit peanut butter cup that I could just eat it with a spoon. SO GOOD.
Using a tablespoon or small cookie scoop, portion out the peanut butter filling, and roll them into balls. Once you’re done, stick a toothpick into the center of each one and pop them into the freezer until they’re nice and firm, about 30 minutes.
You want them to be able to withstand being dipped into warm melted chocolate, and not start to fall apart. This amount of time does the trick!
Next, you’ll melt together chocolate chips and vegetable shortening, then dip the peanut butter balls so just a small circle at the top is still visible. The shortening helps to thin the chocolate and keep it from clumping up when melted, and I use it anytime I am coating something in chocolate (if you prefer not to use shortening, check out some alternatives in the recipe notes section below).
Finally, pop these babies into the refrigerator to make sure the chocolate is totally set (a couple of hours), then eat to your heart’s content!
Buckeyes Recipe Notes
Some tips for making the best buckeyes, ever!
Save This Recipe
Enter your email address, and we'll send it straight to your inbox!
- Do not use natural peanut butter for these, it is much too oily. You want to reach for a traditional jar of peanut butter such as Jif, Skippy, or your favorite brand.
- You can use salted butter and omit the salt, if you’d prefer.
- While the recipe calls for chocolate chips, you can also use the same amount of bar chocolate, finely chopped. Feel free to substitute dark chocolate or milk chocolate if you’d like.
- I spoke above about the benefits of using vegetable shortening, but if you prefer not to use shortening, you can substitute coconut oil (use refined so the flavor is neutral and you don’t get coconut flavor in your buckeyes!). You could also substitute candy melts or something like CandiQuik for both the chocolate and shortening (though not nearly as delicious as real chocolate!). Follow the directions on the packaging for melting instructions.
Storage Tips
Make sure your buckeyes stay fresh for as long as possible!
- The buckeyes should be stored in an airtight container in the refrigerator to keep them nice and fresh. Stored in this way, they will keep for about 1 month (although good luck keeping them that long without eating them all, ha!).
- You can also freeze buckeyes in an airtight container or freezer ziploc bag for up to 3 months.
So there you have it! One of my oldest, most-loved Christmas recipes, and it could not be simpler to make or a bigger hit wherever you take them.
Does your family make these? Is the recipe similar, or do you put a spin on them, like adding Rice Krispies? I’ve heard about that and am intrigued!
If You Like This Buckeyes Recipe, Try These:
- Buckeye Brownies
- Buckeye Peanut Butter Cup Cookies
- Homemade Peanut Butter Cups
- Peanut Butter Fudge
- Peanut Butter Cup Bars
Watch the Recipe Video:
Peanut Butter Buckeyes Recipe
Ingredients
- 1½ cups (405 g) creamy peanut butter
- 1 cup (227 g) unsalted butter, at room temperature
- ½ teaspoon (0.5 teaspoon) vanilla extract
- Pinch (Pinch) salt
- 4 cups (454 g) powdered sugar
- 4 cups (680 g) semisweet chocolate chips
- ¼ cup (46 g) vegetable shortening
Instructions
- Line cookie sheet with wax or parchment paper; set aside.
- In a large bowl, stir together the peanut butter, softened butter, vanilla extract, and salt with a wooden spoon. Add the powdered sugar a little bit at a time, stirring it into the peanut butter mixture until it is completely incorporated.
- Roll the peanut butter mixture into 1-inch balls. Set them on the prepared cookie sheet and insert a toothpick into the top of each ball. Chill in freezer until hard, approximately 30 minutes.
- In a heatproof medium bowl, combine the chocolate chips and shortening. Place the bowl over a small saucepan with 1 inch of water placed over low heat. Stir occasionally, until the chocolate is completely melted and smooth. Keep the bowl over the saucepan of barely simmering water. Using the toothpick as a “handle”, dip the peanut butter balls into the chocolate, leaving a small circle exposed on the top of each ball. Place the balls back on the cookie sheet and refrigerate until the chocolate is set, approximately 2 hours.
- Once the buckeyes are set, remove the toothpicks and if you’d like, you can use your finger to smudge the peanut butter dough together on the top of the buckeye to cover the hole where the toothpicks were. Store the buckeyes in an airtight container with wax paper between layers in the refrigerator for up to 1 month.
Notes
- Do not use natural peanut butter for these, it is much too oily. You want to reach for a traditional jar of peanut butter such as Jif, Skippy, or your favorite brand.
- You can use salted butter and omit the salt, if you’d prefer.
- While the recipe calls for chocolate chips, you can also use the same amount of bar chocolate, finely chopped. Feel free to substitute dark chocolate or milk chocolate if you’d like.
- I spoke above about the benefits of using vegetable shortening, but if you prefer not to use shortening, you can substitute coconut oil (use refined so the flavor is neutral and you don’t get coconut flavor in your buckeyes!). You could also substitute candy melts or something like CandiQuik for both the chocolate and shortening (though not nearly as delicious as real chocolate!). Follow the directions on the packaging for melting instructions.
- Buckeyes can be frozen for up to 3 months in an airtight container or freezer ziploc bag.
Did you make this recipe?
Leave a review below, then snap a picture and tag @thebrowneyedbaker on Instagram so I can see it!
Update Notes: This recipe was originally published in December 2007. Updated in December 2014 with new photos, and refreshed in December 2018 with more new photos, a video, and recipe tips.
[photos by Ari of Well Seasoned]
Too soft. Too much butter. It was all wasted
I usually read the comments before I make a recipe but I didn’t do that this time! I will surely do that every time from now on! Tooooooo soft. What a mess! 😡
I think the butter might be wrong on this recipe. Is it supposed to be 1/2 cup? I made these and they are so soft I have to keep them in the freezer. Can’t even be left out for a few min before softening up and getting gushy.
Michelle, do you have any idea of the consistency of the peanut butter mixture after being in a fridge for several hours? I really like peanut butter patties rather than buckeyes, but somehow I have lost my recipe. I tried another, scooped out middles and put in fridge for 3 hours. When I tried to press slightly fatter, using greased/sugared bottom of cup, they were so soft they still stuck to the glass…so I’m looking for something that firms up with refridgeration. Like you, I freeze then before dipping.
I think this is what love would taste like!
My family loved it made this recipe for Christmas delious plenty for everyone!!
Thank you for sharing
You mention using vegetable shortening, can canola oil be used?
Hi Carol, I like refined coconut oil better since it is solid at room temperature, like shortening.
Made it but my buckeyes spread out when baking
why would that be
This is a no bake recipe.
I have been making buckeyes for years. I won a few contests at Christmas parties. It’s getting harder for me to make dishes. My question is I have a batch of buckeyes. I may have used the mixer for to long. Most of it is powder. Can I fix this?
Your recipe has a typo in it. It calls for 1 FULL cup of butter. It should be a half cup of butter! Unfortunately, I did not learn this until after I mixed everything. Every other recipe on the Internet calls for a half cup of butter, not a full cup.
I could not roll the dough. It was a huge hassle and I couldn’t figure out why.
Thought you’d like to know so you can edit this!
I’ve made these before and always struggle with the chocolate dipping. I like your idea of setting the toothpick before popping them in the freezer. How do you deal with the little hole left by the toothpick, though? Thanks. (p.s. I followed your recipe for blueberry pie this Thanksgiving, and it was an unequivocal hit!)
Hi Danielle, I just use my thumb or finger to smudge over the hole.
Very easy and fast. Thank you for a great recipe. Question: can you keep the left over chocolate and re-use on another batch. I had a lot of chocolate left over.
Hi Barb, I’m glad you enjoyed them! Yes, you can reuse the chocolate for another batch.
My grandma Jessie used to make these every Christmas. My mouth would start to water for them around November! I lost her recipe for them years ago, and was so excited when I saw your recipe!😊😁😃 Thanks so very much!
Ok to use margarine in place of butter? Possibly already answered this in comments, apologize if so, i did not see it when I quickly scanned over comments. Thank you!
I know it will seem like sacrilege but I made a teeny change to your recipe and people (who have had Buckeyes many times before) are losing their minds! They keep asking me what the secret ingredient is and I won’t tell them but I’ll confess it to you….
I added scant 1/2 tsp maple extract and 1/4 cup brown sugar and one extra pinch of salt. It adds a molassesy, caramelly undertone that is subtle but definitely adds a nuance to this already amazing treat. The extra salt helps balance the extra sugar.
Try it some time! :-))))
Thanks for sharing your idea, that sounds wonderful!
Why do buckeye recipes always specify creamy peanut butter? I’ve made them with crunchy peanut butter many times and love them that way.
I was just wondering about that. My preference is for crunchy.
These are just plain perfect! Better than any peanut butter cup on the market! Soft and creamy and peanut buttery and chocolatey! YUM! Thank you for yet another amazing recipe!
These have been a Christmastime favorite for me since I was a young child when my “Grandma” Downey (not blood family, but as good as!) would make them. She added lightly crushed Rice Krispies to hers, but the last several years I’ve been making them with puffed quinoa. The puffed quinoa adds a similar texture, but it’s smaller and easier to manage, plus it has the bonus of being gluten-free for my friends who need that.
I love your blog and recipes, and not even because I was raised in my beloved Pittsburgh, but now live in Florida. I was challenged to a buckeye bakeoff this Christmas by my mother-in-law and daughter. My question is how to get the holes from the toothpicks to go away? I am a firm believer that buckeyes should not have the toothpick hole shown in the finished product! Thank you! Have a very blessed Christmas!
Hi Lynn, Thank you for the kind words! As for covering up those toothpick holes, I just use my finger to smudge it closed :) Good luck in your bakeoff!
The recipe I’ve used for more than 30 years does call for the addition of Rice Krispies. Last year as I started to shape the peanut butter balls I realized that I had neglected to add the cereal. Ah well, I thought no one will care, it’s still peanut butter and chocolate. Boy was I wrong! Everyone was so disappointed that they weren’t the “traditional” buckeyes that I’d made for years. You better believe that the Rice Krispies will not be forgotten this year.
It looks so yum! This recipe will definitely be on my Christmas table, thank you for sharing!
Being an Ohioan, we had these every Christmas. They are my favorites. So smooth & creamy. Better than Reece’s cups. So easy to make too. Really. Just have to be a little patient and let the PB balls get hard do you can dip them better.
Hi I am enquiring about your recipe, there is not enough of a detailed description “cup” what size cup please ? Thanks Ben
Hi Ben, A standard measuring cup. I will be updating the recipe with weight measurements, as that might help.
When making the bullseyes I don’t have any sort of Crisco nor coconut oil.My question is can I make these using vegetable oil .? That’s all I have in my pantry.tks Mrs.Wolfe
Yes, vegetable oil should work!
Not sure why but I had to use a lot more powdered sugar to be able to form the peanut butter balls, other than that they turned out grate. I used coconut oil instead of vegetable shortening.
Can Buckeyes be frozen before dipping in chocolate
Yes, I think that would be just fine.
Do you have any recommendations for sticky pb batter? This is the 2nd year in a row that my batter has come out sticky and difficult to roll. I’ve added a little more powdered sugar, but I am trying to avoid super sweet buckeyes. The batter is currently sitting in the fridge to hopefully harden up a bit to help me roll them. Otherwise, I LOVE this recipe and use it every year.
Hi Sharon, Hmmm I usually have the opposite problem and they tend to be too dry. Try adding some finely crushed graham cracker crumbs. I use those in my peanut butter bars and they add a little texture that might help yours firm up!
Oh these are amazing, who isn’t a sucker for peanut butter and chocolate!
I love buckeyes too!! I remember someone bringing them for birthday treat in 1st grade (before the days of no-peanut rules – haha!) and falling in love!! My husband and I firmly believe that peanut butter and chocolate are the most perfectly perfect combo there is!! Trader Joe’s Dark Chocolate PB cups are basically in our house at all times:) Lat year, I tried a recipe that year that added nutritional yeast to the peanut butter portion. Have you tried that? It does make it reminiscent of the traditional Reese’s cups, but I can’t get past the funkiness smell/taste it adds. Your version looks delicious!
Hi Maria, I’ve never tried nutritional yeast (never heard of it in buckeyes until now!). I’ve had luck adding some finely crushed graham cracker crumbs for more texture.
my peanut butter is to sticky to form into balls.. what can i do