Malted Vanilla Milkshake
After buying malted milk powder for the first time recently and making my inaugural malted milk recipe (the Chocolate Malted Whopper Cookies – yum!), I knew without a doubt that my next stop would be a milkshake. I mean, how could it not be?! Malted milkshakes are pretty much iconic in America. They make me envision corner-shop candy and soda fountain shops in the 1950’s. Sometimes I wish I would have grown up in that era – everything about it mesmerizes me. But we’re in the here and now, and great milkshakes are still coveted today. While I admittedly don’t have them often, there is just something so satisfying about a really great, thick, creamy milkshake. And vanilla is by far my favorite. Off I went to churn up my favorite vanilla bean ice cream so I could make a perfectly authentic, homemade malted milkshake.
So, this is pretty much the best milkshake ever. Thick, creamy, ice-cold, malt-y, and with 100% homemade ice cream. I can’t imagine anything better. Also, I love that you can see the little vanilla bean flecks in the milkshake! If you like chocolate or strawberry shakes, just use your favorite flavor of ice cream and keep everything else the same.
Disclaimer: I have no idea how many calories or fat grams are in this milkshake. Ignorance is bliss and everything in moderation. Enjoy! :)
One year ago: Peanut Butter-Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies[/donotprint]
Malted Vanilla Milkshake
- 1 cup (132 g) 2 big scoops of your favorite ice cream (I used my homemade vanilla bean)
- ½ cup (122 ml) cold milk
- 2 to 3 tablespoons malted milk powder, depending on how malt-y tasting you like it
- ½ teaspoon (0.5 teaspoon) vanilla extract
- Combine all ingredients in a blender until smooth. Pour into a tall glass and enjoy!
Did you make this recipe?
Leave a review below, then snap a picture and tag @thebrowneyedbaker on Instagram so I can see it!
I like chocolate but I LOVE vanilla!
Followed a similar recipe when I was a ‘soda jerk’ in the early 1970’s but used
vanilla syrup instead of vanilla extract. Also used to make a vanilla sundae…vanilla ice cream, a squirt of vanilla syrup on the bottom and top, then finish with whipped cream.
Just made it and it’s fantastic, perfect proportions! So happy I can make my family’s favorite treat at home now without paying a fortune for it! Thanks for sharing! So delicious!
Try a dash of Nutmeg in the shake, It’s even better..
1This made a DELICIOUS malt! Sorry, we drank them before I could get a picture. Will definitely make these again!
What brand of malted milk powder do you use?
Hi Marale, I use King Arthur Flour.
It was delicious, and I approve its thickness (I love thick milkshakes). I calculated calories for you: 428 calories if you use skim milk, but regular vanilla ice cream.
It’s clear you didn’t grow up in the 50s, because in those days–especially in new England–milkshakes were definitely NOT thick. They were very drinkable. At most, a milkshake incorporated one very small scoop–which was the size of a melon ball–of ice cream! Some soda fountains didn’t use ANY ice cream in their ‘shakes. A “frappe” (pronounced “frap”) was thicker, but even then contained just one scoop of ice cream. ASadly, stores like the Dairy Queen came in and changed what was a great drink to accompany a hamburger into something that doesn’t deserve the name “milkshake.”
I grew up in NY, and malts were always thin, but I think that was an eastern thing. My husband grew up in the west and he remembers thick malts. I live in the west now and I can’t drink them here — way too thick. You need a spoon, not a straw.
So simple and such a wonderful treat, Michelle.
Ooooh, I should NOT have read this post right before dinner! Now I’m craving a milk shake!!
I love a cold, thick milkshake! Chocolate is my favorite but this one looks fabulous too!
Gelato, vanilla ice cream and milk shake my favourites! Thanks.
Yum! I always think of malt powder as being coupled with chocolate shakes, and I’m much more of a vanilla girl. Love this!
as i kid, i remember going to the local candy/soda fountain shop & ordering a vanilla milkshake
& a big salty pretzel rod…easy, sweet & uncomplicated!
thanks for the trip down “memory lane” & i certainly will be creating this shake…very soon!
Oh yum. This looks absolutely perfect!
How about the milkshake and the Chocolate Whopper Cookies together, Yum! BTW, I get my background papers from Michael’s also. Love that store.
OMG. I so want one of these…now!
You can’t go wrong with ice cream!!! I love milkshakes! :D
Oh my goodness, I am now transforming my mom’s birthday into a malt party. She loves malted everything, so cookies and milkshakes here we come!!
Yum! I worked in an ice cream shop where we used to make malted milkshakes… I love the flavor that the malted milk adds… This recipe totally takes me back!
Hmmm – this looks and sounds so comforting and delicious. Wish I could sip on one right now.
I love malted milkshakes. So yummy!
Over the years, I’ve come to love vanilla more than chocolate (tastes change as you age, I guess!), and I know I would absolutely LOVE this. It looks delicious!
My very first job was working in a Mom & Pop ice cream kind of shop. I was addicted to the Vanilla Malt. Thanks for reminding me :)
Ooooh – I’ve never worked with malted milk powder before, but this post and recipe sure are inspiration enough to get me to give it a try. Thanks for this!
I love your pictures. What did you use for the pink back drop?
Thanks Laura! It’s just a piece of pink paper that I found in the art supplies section of Michael’s (they have tons of different colors).
A milkshake like this makes me ignore any lactose intolerance. Love the pics!
Oh how we love ice cream at our house! YUM, this looks fabulous!
Ooh gorgeous! I want one of these now!
That sounds great, I’ve really got to try adding malted milk powder to a few things.
Is that a McDonald’s straw? I got hit with some serious nostalgia when I saw the picture.
Haha! It’s actually a super old Wendy’s straw! I couldn’t find long straws at the store, and then found this old Wendy’s one in the back of the silverware drawer, so I used that!
Mmm I love malt in milkshakes! This looks like something I would have had as a kid. Yum!
MAlted cookies and now malted milkshake?! Marry me!
I LOVE milkshakes. My favroite milkshake ever was a peanut butter cup flavored one from a “fancy” diner. I may have to recreate that soon:-)
I really have to try that! I tend to put the malted powder in with chocolate ice cream or recently in my homemade hot chocolate mix. That’s a winner too! I have put it in pancake batter but never in a vanilla milkshake. Something about it seems so obvious. Thank you for another great idea.
Malted milkshakes are my favourite!! Great shot in that nice glass.
Ignorance is bliss and life is too short NOT to enjoy a glorious milkshake like that – yum!! :)
Where do you find the malted milk powder?? Baking aisle?
In our local store it is in with the powdered drinks and instant hot chocolates.
I actually ordered mine from King Arthur Flour the last time I placed an order, but thanks Penny for pointing out where it can be found in the grocery store!
You can’t go wrong with a thick milkshake – this looks amazing!