, which was co-authored by Sarah Billingsley and Amy Treadwell. Sarah is a native of Pittsburgh and used to write for the local newspaper, the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette. I worked with the food editor there to write a piece about the popularity of whoopie pies, their history, and a bit about Sarah and the book:
Whoopie pies with your favorite s'mores flavors
Ingredients:
For the Graham Cracker Whoopie:
-
1½
cupsgraham flour
-
¾
cupall-purpose flour
-
1½
teaspoonsbaking powder
-
½
teaspoonsalt
-
4
tablespoonsunsalted butter(at room temperature)
-
4
tablespoonsvegetable shortening
-
1
cuppacked dark brown sugar
-
2
large eggs
-
½
cupbuttermilk
-
2
tablespoonsmilk
-
1
teaspoonbaking soda
-
1
teaspoonwhite vinegar
-
1
teaspoonvanilla extract
For the Classic Marshmallow Filling:
-
1½
cupsMarshmallow Fluff(or other prepared marshmallow cream, which will do in a pinch)
-
1¼
cupsvegetable shortening
-
1
cupconfectioners' sugar
-
1
tablespoonvanilla extract
For the chocolate ganache:
-
8
ouncesmilk chocolate chips(or solid chocolate, finely chopped)
-
½
cupheavy cream
Directions:
-
1. Position a rack in the center of the oven and preheat the oven to 375 degrees F. Line two baking sheets with parchment paper.
-
2. In a medium bowl, stir together both flours, baking powder, and salt.
-
3. In the work bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, beat together the butter, shortening and brown sugar until light and creamy, about 3 minutes. Add the eggs and the buttermilk and beat until combined.
-
4. In a measuring cup, combine the milk, baking soda, and vinegar. Add the milk mixture to the batter along with the flour mixture and beat on low speed until just combined. Add the vanilla and beat on medium speed for about 2 minutes, until completely combined.
-
5. Using a spoon, drop about 1 tablespoon of batter onto one of the prepared baking sheets and repeat, spacing them at least 2 inches apart. Bake one sheet at a time for about 10 minutes each, or until the cakes begin to brown. Remove from the oven and let the cakes cool on the sheet for at least 5 minutes before transferring them to a rack to cool completely.
-
6. Make the Marshmallow Filling: In the work bowl of a stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment, beat together the Marshmallow Fluff and the vegetable shortening, starting on low and increasing to medium speed until the mixture is smooth and fluffy, about 3 minutes. Reduce mixer speed to low, add the confectioners' sugar and the vanilla, and beat until incorporated. Increase mixer speed to medium and beat until fluffy, about 3 minutes more.
-
7. Make the Chocolate Ganache Filling: Put the chocolate in a large, heatproof bowl. Heat the cream in a large, heavy saucepan over medium heat just until it bubbles. Pour the hot cream over the chocolate in the bowl and let it sit for about 10 minutes, until the chocolate is melted. Stir with a wooden spoon or spatula until smooth. Allow the mixture to rest at room temperature until firm enough to spread, about 2 hours. You may also refrigerate the mixture for about 30 minutes, until it is firm enough to spread, stirring every 10 minutes.
-
8. Assemble the whoopie pies: Pipe or spread (whatever your preferred method) a layer of chocolate ganache filling onto the flat side of one of the cakes. Using the same method, top the chocolate filling with the marshmallow filling. Top it with another cake, flat-side down. Repeat with the rest of the cakes and filling.
-
* Note: I know many people are opposed to vegetable shortening, but it really is a necessary ingredient. It gives the cakes their characteristic lift and lightness, and the rounded shape. It is also a crucial component of the classic marshmallow filling. I can attest to both of these after reviewing my mom's old recipes for gobs!
Nutrition:
Calories: 326kcal
Fat: 19g
Saturated fat: 7g
Cholesterol: 27mg
Sodium: 117mg
Potassium: 58mg
Carbohydrates: 36g
Fiber: 1g
Sugar: 25g
Protein: 2g
Vitamin A: 180%
Vitamin C: 0.1%
Calcium: 43%
Iron: 0.7%
These are good but not like a smore very much
I love whoopie pies! My favorite is the chocolate peppermint!
I love whoopies
I am so frustrated! I make your recipes ALL the time, and have great success with each and every one – except these!! I have made these three times now, and the last two times the whoopie/cookies were flat as boards. I just don’t get it. The first time, I had domes of beautiful graham whoopies, and these last two times I have flat, greasy, crumbly chewie halves. I can barely bring myself to waste a half a pound of good chocolate on these. The first flop, I threw out the cookies. But now, I am trying again, and the same! What do you think went wrong?
Hmm might have something to do with your leavener, or if you are greasing the cookie sheets instead of using parchment. If everything else is the same, I’m not sure why else they would turn out fine one time and flat the others.
I only know them as Whoopie pies, and I just found out what they were about a month ago while watching Food Network. I have never had one and I was thinking about trying to make some my family :) They look so good!
Hi
The recipe requires confectioners’ sugar for the marshmallow filling, can I just use granulated sugar instead?
Thanks
Hi Julie, You can’t really sub granulated sugar here because it won’t dissolve into the mixture the way powdered sugar will.
I am from South Africa and recently stumbled upon your blog – it is beyond fabulous!!!
Please could you tell me what the following is:
Marshmallow Fluff (or other prepared marshmallow cream)?
I have never seen this in our stores before and wondered if you could tell me what I could use as a substitute?
Tx a mil!
This is basically like a spreadable melted marshmallow concoction. To substitute, you could make your own marshmallow frosting. I recently made s’mores cupcakes with a homemade marshmallow frosting that you could use here:
https://www.browneyedbaker.com/2011/07/13/smores-cupcakes-recipe/
the smore whoopie pie was really good. i just had to make them and try them when i read about them on the site. thats a whoopie pie also something that is really good use ur favorite cookie and have a cookie whoopie thanks
I was wondering if you could substitute the graham flour for a different one because I can’t find it anywhere!!??
Hi Carmella – It is available online at King Arthur Flour, but if you’d rather not order, it sounds like a reader above had good luck processing graham crackers in the food processor and using that instead.
I couldn’t find graham flour, either – even at Mrs Green’s, an all natural grocery near me. So I improvised, and processed some Mi-Del organic graham crackers in the Cuisinart. And I used good milk chocolate chips for the ganache, since when I do s’mores on a campout, I use good ol’ Hershey’s milk chocolate – so I wanted that same flavor. It worked great. These are definitely on my make again list. Tks for sharing!
I’ve tried looking for the graham flour and can not find it. I really, really want to try this recipe out. Can you tell me where I may be able to find this type of flour?
Hi Tiffany, I found it in the organic section of the regular supermarket, where other flours like almond and rice flour are found. If you don’t have any luck, you could always order it as well:
http://www.kingarthurflour.com/shop/items/king-arthur-whole-wheat-pastry-flour-/-graham-flour-3-lb
For me, they’ve never been Whoopie Pies or Gobs – they’re a cookie sandwich! That sounds much more nutritious.
I prefer the basic chocolate (like an oreo), but it’s also the only way I’ll eat oatmeal cookies. But I must say, these S’mores Whoopie Pies might become my favorite!
I don’t like using processed foods, so I made my own marshmallow fluff. The second I added the shortening, it completely deflated. I had to add a ton of extra powdered sugar to save the consistency and even then, it was too runny. Just posting so anyone else thinking about using homemade knows what’s coming! I think next time I’m just going to put mini marshmallows on top of the ganache and broil it.
I live in Kazakhstan, where I am the principal of an international school. We can’t get Marshmallow fluff – but can get jet puffed Marshmallows. Is there any way to modify the marshmallow filling so that marshmallows can be used?
Hi Joahna, You could make a marshmallow frosting to use in place of of the marshmallow fluff concoction. Here is a recipe:
http://smittenkitchen.com/2008/02/homemade-devil-dog-ding-dong-or-hostess-cake/
I made these and they were okay, but I prefer the traditional chocolate with white filling ones.
I lived in Pittsburgh in the 80’s and forgot that they call these ‘gobs.’ Thanks for this post! (I call them Whoopie Pies, though, even though they are sold as “Moon Pies.”) Great post!
I have to admit that I don’t believe I’ve ever had a whoopie pie. *gasp* I can’t wait to give it a try!
They definitley are the rage at the moment! I wanted to do red/white/blue ones for Bastille Day (french holiday) but did more authentic French things instead :)
I have only known them as Whoopie Pies! My favorite flavor is the classic chocolate with marshmallow filling!!
I was speed-scrolling trying to catch up on my Google reader, and these pictures stopped my dead in my tracks! GAH! Heaven! I’m totally making these this week when my aunt and cousins come to visit! :D
Sucks that I missed the deadline! :(
Never heard them called gobs before, but we called them devil dogs – like the Drake’s cake – when they had marshmallow in the filling, and whoopie pies when they were straight up vanilla cream.
Totally Whoopie Pie!! My fave is red velvet – CLASSIC!!!!
Right across the border in Ohio they’re Whoopie Pies. So far, pumpkin whoopie pies are my fave but this S’mores recipe just might replace it!
PA girl-here in our parts they are Gobs – my favorite is the pumpkin gob that comes out during fall in Amish country – those Amish woman make the best gobs hands down
after living just on the outskirts of Pittsburgh…they definitely are Gobs!
Whoopie pies definitely! At a local bakery, my friend makes incredible chocolate whoopie pies with a cream cheese filling. Amazing!
I know them as whoopie pies. So far I’ve only tried the classic chocolate with marshmallow filling.
What a cool idea – they look fantastic!
It’s a whoopie pie! I love the classic chocolate ones with the marshmallow filling. Although, the pumpkin ones are great in the fall.
It’s a whoopie pie! I have never had one that is homemade before. Yum.
It is a whoopie pie! I’ve never made or even had a whoopie pie before! This book would be a great push in the whoopie pie direction. :)
You know, I’ve never had one… So I have no idea what they’re called!
It is definitely called a whoopie pie for me, and I love pumpkin whoopie pies with cream cheese filling! Love this book!
Whoopie pies! And I love the classic — chocolate with white filling.
I’ve always called them whoopie pies as well.. this is a very popular dessert in our household=)
One issue i’m having.. i can’t find graham flour around here=( I live in a fairly small town in PA.. maybe i’ll have to order it online
I love whoopie pies. There are hundreds of combinations. ! They are like a “poor man’s”” macaron.. LOOL. Would love to see a contest..original pies, and how many cool combinations people could come up with ***hint HInt** :)
I’ve always called them whoopie pies, and I’ve only ever had the chocolate/marshmallow combo. But this s’mores version will probably become my favorite!
I’m originally from MA, and we called them whoopie pies up there – but more importantly, my absolute favorite whoopie pie is the classic chocolate flavored with a creamy smooth vanilla center that comes from Beiler’s, an authentic Pennsylvania Dutchbakery located at the Reading Terminal Market in Philadelphia, PA. They are a heavenly experience, to say the least.
My mom always called them Gob Pies! She’d make a batch of chocolate gobs for my dad and brother’s marathons. I earned my own batch last October when I crossed the finish line of my first marathon :)
GOBS! I am a Pittsburgh girl through and through! I live in central PA now, and everyone here calls them Whoopie Pies, but I stand my ground on the Gobs. :)
I actually have always called them “Whoopie Pies,” but as I think of it, I like really DESCRIPTIVE names. Of course, in that case, both “Gobs” and “Whoopie Pies” work, don’t they?
I think my favorite flavor is the pumpkin flavored ones in Amish Country. Chocolate is always nice, but the pumpkin ones taste like fall and Amish and country all rolled into one. They’re my favorite… until I try the S’mores ones above!
It is most definitely a whoopie pie, and I absolutely love them. My favorite flavor is chocolate chip cookie with white yumminess in the middle! :-)
To me they are definitely whoopie pies! Pumpkin whoopie pies with a cinnamon and vanilla cream are where it’s at.
I call it a whoopie pie I like and make the pumpkin and spice flavour. It tastes like the ones I loved eating as a child and still do.
I would call these Whoopie Pies! I have never had one, but I sure want to try one now! I would probably like anything that had chocolate in it! The Whoopie Pie book sounds great!
I’ve never heard of gobs, so to me they’re definitely whoopie pies. I don’t think I’ve ever technically had a whoopie pie, sadly, but these look like a good recipe to start with!
Whoopie Pie all the way!!! I really like the classic whoopies but these sound fabulous!
As a fellow brown eyed baker, I must say, Well Done!
I agree with Terry who commented above. As a life long Pittsburgher, we always called them Gobs. They were quite a chore to make b/c my Mom’s recipe made over 100 of the little cakes. I like the old chocolate/white cream the best, but Pumpkin with cream cheese filling are also high on my list.
I know them as Whoppie Pies. I use to eat alot of store bought chocolate ones as a child my fave. As an adult I have tried and liked red velevt ones. Yummy
I’ve never heard of “gobs,” so definitely a whoopie pie :) You know, I haven’t really been able to get into whoopie pies, but now that I’m seeing these?? I might be changing my mind!! They’ve definitely been bookmarked and hopefully I’ll try them soon :)
Your photos are so beautiful!
Can’t wait to try this recipe. I call them whoopie pies.
I know them as whoopie pies but I’ve never actually had one…hopefully that will change soon!
Defnitely whoopie pies. Have made a few varities… Banana with a simple buttercream filling was a huge hit, but I ahd the most fun making a traditional chocolate version with homemade marshmallow fluff frosting. Mmmmm… :)
Whoopie Pies – I was going to say Moon pies, but all of the moon pies I have ever had are a cookie bottom and top, marshmallow middle, and dipped in chocolate.
I have never made them before but really want to try the Smore version!
Congrats on the top 9!!!
and if those pies aren’t a good reason to make whoopie, nothing is!!
they look so very very good!!!
all the best
Dennis
They are definitely “whoopie pies”! I have only had red velvet with white filling – but they are divine!
Whoopie Pies, I have never had any but I am thinking about making some very soon
I have always known them as whoopie pies and chocolate with whipped cream filling will always be my favorite but I can’t wait to try this recipe!
Whoopie pies! Of Course!!! Sounds alot more fun thatn Gobs! I have only tasted the chocolate, but the other flavors sound scumptious!
Oooh, I saw this book at Sur La Table last night! I had a strawberry whoopie pie recently and it was darn good :)
I’ve never heard whoopie pies called gobs before so I’d have to say that they’re whoopie pies! And I’ve only tried them once, the original chocolate with white icing. Would love to try out other variations in this cookbook though to find a favourite! These smores ones look like they could be a grand contender.
They are whoopie pies and i love chocolate ones!
I’ve only ever known them as whoppie pies….and I’ve never had one :-( I was wondering though, Could I use graham crackers run through the food processor?
It’s a whoopie pie, and they are delicious!
I’ve never heard of a gob. I’ve had red velvet whoopie pies and pumpkin whoopie pies, and there’s no way I could choose a favorite. I love the combination of cake and frosting, so I love all whoopie pies.
I don’t think I’ve ever had a whoopie pie. At least, it wasn’t called a whoopie pie. However, it reminds me of one of my most favorite snacks ever – Oatmeal Cream Pies by Little Debbie. I bet there is a recipe out there for a Whoopie Pie with oatmeal cookie and cream filling, right? If so, send it my way!!!
They are Gobs, and the best is the original chocolate with fluffy white filling!
I know them as Whoopie pies. And the best I’ve made were pumpkin chocolate chip with vanilla filling. Yum!
It’s a whoopie pie. And my Aunt makes the best ones, chocolate with marshmallow filling!
I think they are whoopie pies because I have never heard of gobs before. I have only had a red velvet whoopie pie before so it wins by default; I’d love to try more flavors though!!
It’s whoopie pies for me, but the shortening in all of them turns me off, always!
In my part of the country they are whoopie pies for sure. When I heard gobs in Pittsburgh, I didn’t even know they are the same thing!
None of this whoopie pie nonsense…they are GOBS = ) And, btw, these smores gobs look fantastic!
Well, as a fellow Pittsburgh girl, I’d have to call them “gobs” as well. The chocolate with vanilla center is my historical favorite – HOWEVER – I think the s’mores may soon claim the title! :-) Time to hit the baking aisle for graham flour… Thanks for sharing this great recipe!!!
Whoopie pie for me! I am from Pennsylvania and they are very popular here. A friend from Connecticut calls them gobs though. My favorite is red velvet with white cream center!
This book looks awesome – and they are whoopie pies to me. :) I have only made chocolate with a peanut butter filling and they were delicious. But anything s’mores is my favorite and I can’t wait to try this version!
They’re whoopie pies to me! My favorite is chocolate with a marshmallowy buttercream in the middle.
Whoppie Pies! Pumpkin whoopie pies area fav of mine!
I’m from Texas and have only known them as Whoopie Pies! I’ve of course had the chocolate with white icing, but have also tried lemon and red velvet. Red Velvet cake is an all time favorite of mine, so Red Velvet Whoopie Pies where over the top! Love them!
Never had one!
Whoopie Pie! And my favorite has always been chocolate with vanilla cream. Yum!
They look delicious!! I haven’t heard about gobs before, so they are whoppie pies to me! And… I’ve never had whoopie pies before :-) so couldn’t tell you my favorite flavour.
ricettebarbare at gmail dot com
Definitely whoopie pies as I’ve known them. I’ve only ever had the classic chocolate cookie w/ filling kind. I’d love to see all the different kinds I could make for my friends with that book!
I’d say a whoopie pie and I didn’t even know that there was more than one flavor of them. This recipes looks amazingly delicious…thanks for sharing and thanks for the contest!
vinegrafted@gmail.com
Whoopie pie for sure! And I have had the chocolate kind with white fluffy icing inside! Mmmmmmm!
Whoopie pies, I’ve only had the chocolate ones
They’re whoopie pies to me! My favorites are the classic chocolate with white filling. My friend makes heaps of them for Christmas; makes me always look forward to the holidays!
I’ve heard of Whoopie Pies before, but not Gobs, so I’d say it’s a Whoopie Pie. Besides, I’d rather eat something called a Whoopie Pie. Gob isn’t a very appetizing name! However, I’ve never tired the treat under either name! I’ll have to change that!
Is it weird that I haven’t had a whoopie pie (it’s totally not a gob) before? These look really yummy, and I’m almost tempted to stay up all night makin’ and eatin’ them.
I call them whoopie pies. I don’t believe I’ve ever even heard of a gob. My favorite whoopie pie that I’ve had is an oatmeal whoopie pie with vanilla buttercream filling. But I have a feeling these S’more ones may just be my new favorite after I make them!
cjpeacockbird at gmail dot com.
I have only heard of whoopie pies. I have had a couple and chocolate was my favorite. I think a keylime or lemon would be divine.
I have only heard of them as whoopie pies. Yet, I have never had one. But, I would love to win this cookbook and bake up a storm for the boys and my husband, and extended family!
I have never had a whoopie pie or a gob before–but they look amazing! I’ll have to give them a try!
I don’t know them as either gobs or whoopie pies. Isn’t that pathetic. I didn’t even know they had a name. I have never had them home made either and never imagined there could be so many varieties. My experience has either been vanilla, banana or chocolate flavored store bought individually plastic wrapped somewhat stale pies. I think I would call them gobs just because whoopie pies make me think of whoopie cushions. Anyway, I’m in serious need of some gob education! :)
I have only heard them called Whoopie Pies. My absolute favorite has to be red velvet with a cream cheese filling, although pumpkin whoopie pies with a cinnamon cream cheese filling is amazing too!
Um, I’ve never had a Whoopie Pie or a Gob. How’s that for a confession? They aren’t a west coast thing. I grew up in California and now live in Idaho and I’ve never known anyone who made Whoopie Pies. I’ve seen them all over blogland though and I’d love to learn how to make them.
je2kids(at)yahoo(dot)com
a whoopie pie. never had one so i don’t have a favorite variety.
while not sure about that much rich filling – the cookie part of the smore one looks great …
jacquieastemborski AT comcast DOT net
Neither! Moon pies all the way! :) My favorite are the chocolate ones, although I’m mighty tempted by these smores ones. :)
Whoopie Pies! I’ve never even heard them called Gobs.
The S’mores ones sound de-lish. My favorite are probably the chocolate (Oreo like) ones. And though I haven’t tried banana ones, I love all things banana and would probably love those, too!
It is DEFINITELY a Whoopie Pie. Gobs don’t travel. Certainly not to Philadelphia.
I’m going to make these soon. Yum. Thank you!
I LOVE Whoopie Pies, and had never even thought of a S’more version! I will be trying these soon. Great website!!
Definitely whoopie pies. I like the original with vanilla in the middle… I’m a purist ;)
They are whoopie pies to me. :)
I recently made some carrot cake whoopie pies. They were yummy but I prefer the classic chocolate with marshmallow filling. I can’t wait to try the s’mores!
WHOOPIE PIES!! I love the marshmallow with chocolate…now I am dying to try the s’mores recipe…yum!
Whoppie Pies – Pumpkin, Red Velvet, Creamsicle – Yum, Yum, and Yum
I didn’t know of them until a few months ago (as “Whoopie Pies”), but have made them twice since – once Chocolate with a peanut butter middle, and the other time Chocolata (again!) but with a cream cheese/cool whip middle…both times = YUM!!
Never had a whoopie pie before, but the chocolate vanilla combination look good!
Yep, it’s a whoopie pie. I’ve made several flavors over the years. I also made a S’mores sandwich cookie similar to this but has graham/choc chip cookie base and marshmallow in between them, yummy!
Greetings from a lifelong Pittsburgher where these will always be gobs. I prefer the basic chocolate with white filling but the s’mores version look yummy.
I know them as Whoopie Pies, i have had chocolate and peanut butter and the original. I like the original the best!
Yum! I’ve learned these to be whoopie pies, but they were sadly absent from my childhood.
Whoopie Pies! I love the red velvet with cream cheese frosting…excuse me…I feel the need to go bake.
I have always heard them called Whoopie Pies. My favorite kind…I’ve only had a store bought one :(, but if I win this book I will definitely be trying some new ones! Hope I win.
Gobs…only Gobs, brings back memories of my Aunt Fay from Saltsburg PA who used to make them for us.
I have made and consumed many, they are called whoopie pies. Calling them gobs just doesn’t sound right!
I think the closest thing I’ve had to a gob is a moon pie. These look really yummy! Thanks for the chance to win.
Definitely whoopie pies and I grew up with whoopie pies at every gathering.
They’re whoopie pies! And I’ve only had the chocolate marshmallow combination but can’t wait to try more!!!!
I love the addition of graham flour in your whoopie pies. Such a great idea for a cookbook. Are there carrot cake whoopie pies? If so, i’ll take some of those :)
Actually I’m not totally sure but those look like homemade Moon Pies to me. But I guess I’ve heard them called whoopie pies more than anything else (never heard of gobs). Since I’m a s’mores addict, I’ll just call ’em heaven and say “share please!”
I call them Whoopie Pies. When I was little, I loved the ones that were plain. That was all you could get. Since then I have baked Pumpkin Whoopie Pies and they were incredible. I’ve also eaten chocolate on chocolate ones which was magnificent. My favorite is still the plain ones.
I’ve seen Red Velvet Whoopie Pies too, which I just have to try one of these days. I can’t wait to read this book.
They are definitely whoopie pies and the Oreo ones are the best!
jdkn05@yahoo.com
I’m from Central Pennsylvania, where the Amish are the makers of whoopie pies. Out classic ones are chocolate with white icing, but it’s not marshmallow based. My very favorite are the oatmeal cookie ones. Big, soft oatmeal cookies with that unbelieveable icing sandwiched between, oh they can’t be beat!
Whoopie pies!
I just made the classic chocolate!
Live in Central Il, we don’t see them often, but when you do they are Whoppie Pies!!
Definitely whoopie pies!! What on earth is a gob? My favorite flavor is red velvet with cream cheese frosting!
P.S. Has anyone tried using Spectrum’s Organic All Vegetable Shortening in this or other gob/whoopie pie recipes? Just wondering if the texture still works? Opinions or experiences?
Also, does anyone have a good gluten free whoopie pie/gob recipe to share? My little boy is gluten free, and he would love these treats.
Thanks!
I’ve only heard of them as whoopie pies. I’ve never had one yet. But the smore’s whoopie pies have been on my must bake list for awhile now. I’d love to try the red velvet ones or the chocolate ones! Even the chocolate chip ones on the book cover look good!
Gobs! Disclaimer – I’m from the Pittsburgh region. They are always known as Gobs around here, although I have no idea why. My favorites are the classic chocolate with white fluff frosting middle or pumpkin with cream cheese frosting. However, I hope to soon try this Smore version. They look delicious! Thanks.
They’re Whoopie Pies! I love the pumpkin and the Red Velvet.
I definately call them Whoopie Pies… I like the classic chocolate with cream filling, although carrot cake is nice too!
I’ve never heard of gobs, only whoopie pies – but either way, I’m happy to make and sample all variations!
I grew up with them as whoopie pies. I love carrot cake ones with cream cheese frosting as the filling or the basic chocolate with vanilla frosting. I once made banana ones, but they were not the best.
Cute cookies….if it were not 90 degrees, I would be baking these right now-yum~
Gobs! It is one of my fondest memmories from childhood. I am from Pittsburgh, PA.
Deanna
It’s a whoopie pie to me, and I love oatmeal ones, or pumpkin ones, or oatmeal pumpkin ones…Thanks for the giveaway!
They are “gobs of whoopsie pies” – my grandma made them for as long as I can remember and whenever I see anything about whoopie pies I think of her. By far, her original devil’s food-like cake with cream filling is my favorite :)
I call them whoopie pies. my favorite would be pumpkin with maple filling
I call them Whoopie Pies and I love just plain ole’ chocolate with cream filling. Mmmmm!
I call them Whoppie Pies! My favorite are Pumpkin Whoppies – I made them and was so sad that my Southern Cali friends had no idea what these where!
They are whoopie pies and while the classic is best, the pumpkin ones are really good. I need to check out that cook book!
I love whoopie pies and that is what we have always called them….however I love the term “gobs”! I’m a fan of the classic variety but this post makes me think the smores variety may take the lead!
I’ve only heard of them as whoopie pies, and chocolate with buttercream frosting in the middle is my favorite way to eat them.
I’ve never heard of gobs, so they are whoopie pies for me. I made a whoopie pie recipe once before and wasn’t that impressed, mainly because I thought the buttercream filling was too much. These, on the other hand, look really good and I love the marshmallow and chocolate filling. Can’t wait to try them!
I’ve never heard of these, but they look delicious!
I grew up in Western Pennsylvania calling them gobs, usually referring to the traditional chocolate cake with white filling version. I didn’t even know until recently that they were called ‘whoopie pies’ in other regions. I do like the traditional variety but have taken a liking to the pumpkin cake version. It’s a nice change around the Thanksgiving and Christmas holidays. I wouldn’t mind trying to make them myself with a fillling similar to pumpkin rolls. A nice holiday treat in an individual serving.
it’s a whoopie pie, and i like ’em any way i can get ’em. this smore variation has made my day, though, and i must try them asap. wish you delivered! ;)
You are right, they have become famous now…in fact until a few months ago I didn’t even know what they were! (I’m not American! We don’t have them in Italy). So whoopie pie or gob? No idea….but the sound of the word gob seems so much more fun that I choose gob. Taste? No idea either….but I love everything with vanilla cream so I’ll go with that!
It’s a gob! And I love the classic, chocolate/vanilla cream variety.
When I was a child, my mom used to make these for me and my brothers as a special treat and we called them whoopie pies. Mom only made the basic chocolate with white filling but I have come to like chocolate with peanut buttercream filling…yum!
They’re whoopie pies and chocolate/vanilla filling are my fave!
Mmmmm….whoopie pies!! And I’m all about s’mores this summer. Made huge s’mores cookies for the 4th! Guess I’ll have to try these next time. They look awesome!
To me they’re whoopie pies, I’ve never heard of “gobs” before. Can’t wait to try this recipe, I ve never had a whoopie pie…
Def a whoppie Pie! These look wonderful, cant wait to try!
I call them whoopie pies and my favorite currently is Pumpkin with maple cream cheese filling, but I have a feeling these s’mores ones will be a close competitor.
They are whoopie pies and I love the soft oatmeal with a soft vanilla filling. Thanks for the chance to win. Have a great week-end!
Hi, I would call them Whoopie Pies! I haven’t tried the homemade version, only the storbought (which I am sure don’t hold a candle to the homemade ones) and choclolate I am sure would probably be my fav… Looking at the s’mores recipe and I may just have to give them a try (for my grandbabies of course) real soon… they sound delish!
I know them as whoopie pies, and man are they delicious! I particularly like the kind I made last fall for a “Pie Fest”: chocolate cakes with salted caramel buttercream frosting in the center!
I always knew them as Gobs. But my husband calls them Whoopie Pies. I’ve had and made the chocolate with the white frosting. Yum.
Whoopie pies! I like the classic chocolate with vanilla filling. I too have noticed theuir rising popularity- recently saw them being made on The Martha Stewart Show!
They’re whoopie pies where I come from. I’ve only had the chocolate and white icing kind, which I really like. These look even better. The shortening gives me pause, but I don’t think I can resist these!
It’s definitely a Whoopie Pie! I think this s’mores one may have just risen to the top of my fave flavor list!
I’ve always known them as whoopie pies – my grandmother used to make them all the time! My favorite flavor combo would probably be a personal recipe I made for my friends – double dark chocolate pies with creamy peanut butter filling. Three words: to die for!
Whoopie pie!
And my favorite (so far) is carrot cake with cream cheese frosting filling.
My family is from New England and whoopie pies are soo popular. I have tried to make our favorite flavors into these concoctions like red velvet and pumpkin. I will definitely try these!
Is it a whoopie pie or a gob?
Whopie Pie
And if you have had them before, what is your favorite flavor?
I have yet to have one
I grew up in Western PA & live in Pittsburgh where gobs are gobs (it’s cake, not pie.) I have heard them called “whoopie cookies” in Erie, PA. I like the traditional school bake sale recipe with the chocolate cake and Crisco/Butter filling (I know it’s terrible but good.)
The best I ever ate, however, were in Phoenix, AZ this past March as dessert at “District American Kitchen.” They were red velvet sliders with a light cherry flavoring. NOM NOM NOM
I have always known these as whoopie pies…until I married my husband. :)
Chances are if you are from Pennsylvania or other mid-western states you know them as “Gob’s”. My husband was born and raised in Amish Country. While he is not Amish, all of his neighbors are and his brother married a Mennonite woman who, like many Amish, call these “Gobs”. There origin can be traced as far back as medieval Germany…..eating these delicious treats on horseback no doubt. ;)
It’s a whoopie pie and my favorite is red velvet cake!
I’d have to say they’re whoopie pies. That’s the only way I’ve heard of them and I believe I’ve only eaten the store-bought ones. Sad, I know. I’ll have to give this recipe a try!
They are and always will be Gobs! I make a traditional chocolate with the white cream middle. For Steelers games, I roll the assembled gobs in black and gold sprinkles so that they stick to the cream filling.
My mom always called them sandwich cookies, actually. But she holds strong to the belief that a pie has a crust and can be sliced. My fave sandwich cookie is chocolate chip with chocolate filling!
Honestly, I’ve never heard of these things until this year… and when I DID hear of them I was told they were “whoopie pies.” However that name always makes me think of whoopie cushions (which is not the sort of thing you want to associate with food), so I’d be fine if we just called them gobs!
PS) They’re just as addicting in mini-form. :)
I’ve never heard them called gobs but I like the name. I made a yummy gingersnap whoopie pie at Christmas time. It was yummy!
Woopie Pies.
I like chocolate w/ vanilla filling…Yum!
I had always heard moon pies and whoopie pies. I really haven’t had any, but I would have to say that chocolate with a peanut butter filling sounds great! Yours looking amazing!
They are whoppie pies; I like the classic chocolate with vanilla filling!!
Whoopie Pies are a classic! I have to say chocolate w/vanilla filling is the best… but very few flavors are ‘bad,’ right? :)
Thanks for sharing this recipe!
I never heard them called Whoopie Pies, they were always GOBS. I saw this article in our newspaper this morning. My favorite is the Choc. with white filling. I only heard the term Whoopie cushion our kids use to use as a joke when you sit on it. How did it get this name??????????? Thanks for the recipe.
I lived for a short 6 months in Wexford, PA, too quick to remember if I heard them called gobs. I think of them as whoopie pies and have only had the classic, chocolate with white frosting, and not in a long long time!
They are most definitely Whoopie Pies (pronounced wuh-hoo’-pee) at my house! And chocolate with white cream is my favorite ( http://blessusolord.blogspot.com/2008/09/whoopie-pies.html ), but I do believe I’ll have to try s’mores!
Definitely knew these delicious specimens as whoopie pies! My favorite was always the pumpkin ones with cream cheese filling that always start showing up around Thanksgiving. Yum!
I’ve known them as whoopie pies (although my mom made them recently and called them devil dogs…) I don’t think I’ve ever eaten one aside from the classic chocolate with marshmallow filling, but I think it would be tough to beat ;]
My grandmother made both devil dogs and whoopie pies for my father when he was young. The only difference is the shape. The whoopie pie is round and the devil dog is in the shape of a hot dog bun (long).
Oh my they are GOBS! I have to say that I make a pretty mean pumpkin gob that I can never get enough of at anytime of the year!
our family knows them as Whoopie Pies or Moon Pies (not gobs!) and my fave is the family recipe…chocolate with a marshmallow fluff based filling. they are traditional at all of our parties…and its a big joke of where I hide them and how quickly my brothers and their kids can find them and how many they can consume before they are “revealed” during dessert time (with many missing). I can’t imagine making any other recipes, but I’ve been a little intrigued by the red velvet recipes. I find it interesting they are getting so much press lately – I have made them for years and folks have been a little dumbfounded (what the heck is that??) unless they’ve had exposure to them. I took them to a neighbors party about 5 years ago and they were amazed since they thought they were the only ones round here that made them!
I’m also a fellow Pittsburgher, and they are most definitely called Gobs. I’m not a big chocolate fan, but I think the classic chocolate cake / white icing is hard to beat. The best one I’ve ever had was from an Amish vendor at the farmer’s market in Bridgeville years ago.
whoppie pies! never heard them called gobs before. i love banana with peanut butter or marshmallow filling
I’ve always called them Whoopie Pies! But sadly, I’ve never tried them…guess I should make these!
I’ve never heard of gobs before, only whoopie pies! And I’ve only had/made pumpkin with cream cheese filling, which I adored. But I’m absolutely positive that I’d adore almost any flavor. The red velvet ones are next on my to-do list, and these s’mores ones are so creative… must try them as well. Thanks for the giveaway!
I’ve never heard of whoopie pies referred to as gobs, but clearly a lot of people have. Believe it or not, I’ve actually never tried a whoopie pie. In all fairness, I didn’t grow up in the US, so this is a relatively new discovery. I’m definitely seeing them quite a bit in bakeries and cafés around Los Angeles, so they must be somewhat trendy, although french macarons seem to be a bigger hit!
Its totally a whoopie pie and I’m making these tonight! The firehouse is gonna love them!
-Laura
I’ve always known them as Whoopie Pies! :)
Definitely gobs! I like the classic chocolate.
They are whoopie pies to me, but I have heard them called gobs – actually by Paula Dean.
The traditional chocolate is my favorite, but these s’mores flavored look fantastic and I think I am going to be making them soon.
Whoopie pies for sure. Chocolate with marshmallow creme=pure bliss
Yum…I would say they are woopie pies. I honestly have only had the traditional chocolate with white frosting in the middle. I would love to try some new flavors.
They’ve always been ‘gobs’ to me. The kids thought I made up that name until we were skiing at 7 Springs and bought ‘gobs’ there.
My favorite is Chocolate with white filling (not marshmallow – although the marshmallow is really good too)
I’ll definitely be making the s’mores version. :-)
I call them Whoopie Pies. I’ve only had the chocolate with white filling version, but would like to try others :)
Whoopie Pies!!! I like peanut butter cookies with a white icing filling. YUM!
jreese4peace{at}gmail.com
I’ve always known them as gobs. My favorite so far has been dark chocolate with white frosting and some sort of cherry preserve layered together. I have dreams about a carrot or spice cake version, though. With cream cheese filling, mmm…
We call them Whoopie Pies. I’ve actually never heard them called Gobs. I’ve only made them once, and incidentally, it was the Jalapeno Cornbread whoopie pies from this book! I don’t own it, though…but I’d most certainly LOVE to! :-)
These s’mores whoopie pies look amazing- I’m SO trying those soon!
Whoopie Pies!
They have always been whoopie pies to me. Great recipe!
I am in Pittsburgh and they are called a whole lot of delicious at my house. Whoopie Pies for short. This summer we are using a recipe to make carrot cake whoopie pies. Yo! Double Yo!!!
These look way more delicious than any “Moon Pies” or Little Debbie oatmeal creme pies I’ve had in the South!
Whoopie pies! Chocolate is my favorite!
They are Whoopie Pies where I am from also.. and chocolate will always be my favorite but can’t wait to try your S’mores recipe…
Definitely Whoopie Pies!
I made German Chocolate ones once. The filling was TO DIE FOR!
http://eatrunread.blogspot.com/2010/03/cake-of-week-whoopie-pies-with-coconut.html
I’ve known this type to be called “Gobs” and the chocolate ones with white icing seem to be most common, although, my favorite has been a pumpkin one with cream cheese filling available locally in the the fall. I’m anxious to try some more creative flavors, though! Gobs were always available in the local bakeries. On the other hand, Whoopie Pies, were the marshmallow filled graham cracker-type cookies, completely covered in chocolate and sold commercially packaged and found with the cookies in grocery and convenience stores.
I call them Whoopie Pies. I’ve never tried them though! What better way than to try a recipe out of this cookbook?!
Definitely a whoopie pie :] I would love a vanilla with lemon filling!!!
GOB
Had at 7 springs many years ago while skiing, although I admit they seemed to taste better 30 yrs. ago. I liked the standard chocolate with white cream filling. The snore recipe looks interesting.
Correction Smore
Whoopie pies! My mom makes the best ones – I’m 30 and still request them when she visits. mealsandmayhem@gmail.com
Absolutely a Whoopie Pie! My favorite would have to be Lemon Whoopies with a cherry filling.. delicious!
It looks like glob to me, but I’ve never had a whoppie pie nor heard of them. This is a first for me! That being said, I’ve printed out the recipe and will be making them this weekend. Whoppie!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Whoopie.
When I think of whoopie pies, I visualize the chocolate and marshmallow ones because those are the only ones I’ve eaten. But I was pleasantly surprised to read mentions of lemon ones in the comments here. I love lemon-flavored treats and am now craving whoopie pies of the citrus variety.
I don’t know if I’ve actually had them before! But I have heard of them and they were referred to as whoopie pies. :)
Whoopie pies – and the only flavor I’ve had is the chocolate with the white frosting center. The post with the oatmeal with vanilla icing center sounds like the Little Debbie cakes – would love to try that one!
I love the name Whoopie Pies!! I’ve never had one but it’s been on my to bake list! The S’mores version would taste so awesome!
I’m from Maine and these are Whoopie Pies here. My favorite is pumpkin with cream cheese filling. So good!
I only know them as Whoopie Pies, too. But I’m from California. Is it an east/west coast thing? I’ve only had homemade “classic” whoopie pies, but I’m dying to try a red velvet or pumpkin/cream cheese variety!
It’s a whoopie pie to me. I’ve never had one before, but I have had a moonpie.
It’s a whoopie pie for me! And I love the classic chocolate and white cream combo, brings back childhood memories!
I just call them “sandwich” cookies! My favorite is anything with chocolate!
I love these!! What a great idea. I’d love to make these and take them camping.
I’ve always known them as MOON PIES! Only recently have I been hearing the name Whoopie Pies. Banana is my favorite flavor :)
I always knew them as whoopie pies when I grew up in western PA. When I moved to southeastern MA, I learned that they are called Moon Pies here, as reflected in the semi-famous NRBQ song “RC Cola and a Moon Pie.” My favorite flavor is the classic chocolate cake with the cream filling.
Whoopie pies! I’ve never had them but really want to make my own- I just have to decide which delicious flavor to make!
Whoopie Pies!! My favorite flavor I have made was a fresh strawberry whoopie pie. OOOHH so good!!
I know them as whoopie pies and my favorite is pumpkin with a cream cheese icing center. YUM!
They are definitely whoopie pies to me! But regardless of what you call them, these look absolutely delicious…can’t wait to try them out! :)
Oh this post made me smile! I refuse to call them whoopie pies, they’ll always be gobs to me! This brought back some memories, but my favorite gob was always a pumpkin cake with cream cheese filling that my Mom and I bought at a western PA craft show. Mmmm, yummy!
I’ve only had the smore kind. I made them for the fourth as well! They’re whoopie pies around here.
I know them as Whoopie Pies because when you eat them, you say “Whoopie!!” with a HUGE smile on your face. I have been enjoying these since I was a kid but the only flavor I’ve ever had is chocolate cookie with vanilla cream center. I love S’mores just as much – can’t wait to try this new recipe!!
I am, also, a born and bred Pittsburgh girl (still living there) GOBS it is.
They are known as whoopie pies around here (Oklahoma) and I am a big fan! I’ve had a delicious red velvet version. Yum.
I say whoopie pies, but that’s because I hail from the state of new york; had I come from pittsburgh i’d probably love the steelers and call ’em gobs.
my flavor of choices isn’t necessarily really a flavor, but, my neighborhood bakery has chocolate with pink filling coated with rainbow sprinkles – YUM! they’re so pretty and delicious. whatever we end up calling them– whoopie pies, gobs, moons, gobbie pies– i’m making the s’mores this weekend!
They’re whoopie pies in my world and the only flavor that I remember is chocolate cakes with white creme filling. I must say, however, that new flavor combos sound intriguing!
Ooh! They are totally called Whoopie Pies where I’m from! And I love the classic chocolate with a vanilla icing or marshmallowy center!
Whoopie Pies! I’ve never heard them called gobs before. I’ve never tried them, but the s’mores one might be calling my name! ;)
They are whoopie pies to me, I’ve never heard them called a gob. Sadly, I don’t recall eating one. :(
They’re whoopie pies. I`ve never eaten these cookies before.
It’s only a gob if you also say yins! And the classic chocolate with white is definitely my favorite, although I’ve a mean red velvet variety. lindsaysdiamond@gmail.com
Of course they are Whoopie pies, but are also Gobs of yummyness! I can’t wait to make them. Since finding your site last week I have made 3 different cookies and promised my husbands coworkers that they will have a different cookie each week till I get through all your recipes!! They are so excited and have enjoyed all that I have sent :) Thank you…
I know them as Whoppie Pies, but believe it or not I don’t think I have EVER eaten one! I have seen their rising trend and have wanted to make some myself…maybe this weekend.
You are so right, whoopie pies are the new thing and smores are the best, I have to make these stat! Thanks for sharing!
Doesn’t a whoopie pie go down one’s gob?! Im a pumpkin whoopie pie gal- especially the ones at One Girl Cookies in Brooklyn and in the Baked cookbook!
3rd gen Pittsburgher translated to DC and I declare these GOBS!
I never had Whoopie Pies growing up. They don’t have them overseas. But since back in the States have had few. How about Gingerbread with cream cheese filling> That’s how a friend of mine makes hers.
email = travelingteapot@hotmail.com
Forgot!!!
I never ate whoopie pies but I definitely would like to try them! They look amazing!
Definitely whoopie pies, and classic chocolate with vanilla centre all the way!
I’ve never had a homemade whoppie pie before (for shame!), but I do remember little pre-packed ones I used to snack on at the corner store during the fall. I’m sure the real thing is much much tastier!
They are whoopie pies! And the only kind I’ve ever had are vegan ones my sister’s bakery makes – chocolate with vanilla stuff in the middle. YUM!
I call ’em whoopie pies! I have to admit I like the “classic” flavor best but the s’mores one looks AMAZING!
Actually, my family calls them black moons! For us, they are chocolate cakes filled with cream. I’ve never tried another kind, but would like to!
wow this looks so interesting
stillnotyet100@gmail.com
I know them only as whoopie pies. Unfortunately, I’ve never tried them. I <3 S'mores so this a must try recipe.
Oh, they are definitely Whoopie Pies. I make the chocolate kind with the marshmallow frosting in the center. I really need to expand my horizons and try some other flavors mentioned in the other comments. Who knew?!
whoopie pies! at least here in boston! although i find a lot of people on the west coast don’t even know what they are!
i’m all for the traditional chocolate-marshmallow but i made lemon whoopie pies for NYE and they were super yum!
I’ve never had whoppie pies or gobs, but I have been seeing them all over. I think it’s time I bake myself up a batch!
I’ve only heard of Whoopie Pie, but I’ve never eaten one.
They’re whoopie pies! Pumpkin are my favorite — though I certainly wouldn’t turn down another flavor… :)
I had never heard of whoopie pies until I moved to Boston for school. Never heard of them as gobs. Can’t wait to try the s’mores version. I have a serious love of all things s’mores!
I’ve always called them whoopie pies. My favorite flavor I’ve had is a golden cake with strawberry filling – yum!
They’re whoopie pies, and my favorite flavor is good ol’ chocolate, though I’ve had some delicious pumpkin spice ones as well.
They were introduced to me as Whoopie Pies and I’ve only had Red Velvet.
I call them Whoopie Pies. I haven’t tried them yet, but I’ve been meaning to! Your s’mores ones look delicious.
Thanks for the giveaway!
thenerdswife(at)gmail(dot)com
They are whoopie pies and my favorite by far are the red velvet one!
I know them as Whoopie Pies. Until this year I had only had chocolate with white center, then my mom made red velvet ones with a white center. All things whoopie are good – they make my mouth water just thinking about them!
I am going to go with Whoopie Pies, although I can honestly say I have never eaten one by any name. Might have to whip the S’mores ones up for my niece who loves S’mores, though. Thanks for a great idea!
WHOOPIE PIES! YUM! I had my first “real” whoopie pie while visiting my friend in Connecticut last September. It was chocolate with a delicious buttercream filling! HEAVEN!!
I’ve only heard them refered to as Whoopie Pies. I’ve only had the chocolate w/ vanilla center and I love those! These look delicious though!
I call them Whoopie Pies and can’t wait to try your recipe! I also want to try red velvet cake Whoopie Pies. I love red velvet cake!!
I love whoopie pies! I first saw them at Harrod’s in London… They make the most beautiful ones ever! I hope to win this, fingers crossed.
What are all these people talking about [never heard of GOBS ] ? I grew up in Greensburg PA and we ate Gobs!! Been wanting that cookbook ! YEA FOR GOBS!!!
I’d call it a whoopie pie, but I’ve never had one and would love to try them!
It’s gotta be gob.
I loe whooppee pies! My fav is still red velvet. Its like the perfect cookie/cupcake combo, seriously!
livingonsweettea@yahoo.com
I forgot to answer your question!! They’re definitely whoopie pies to me. No other name can do justice :) Hihi.
RED VELVET WHOOPIE PIES!!!! Love love love love them! I tried making them once by piping circles on a baking sheet (unlike some people who really have the real whoopie pan pan) and they turned out having different sizes. Simple chocolate whoopie pie with traditional marshmallow creme/frosting is also sinful <3 I'd love to get my hands on this book! :<
whoopie pies!!! its just fun to say! whoopieeeeeeeeeeee
RED VELVET WHOOPIE PIES!!!! Love love love love them! :) I tried making them once by piping circles on a baking sheet (unlike some people who really have the real whoopie pan pan) and they turned out having different sizes. Simple chocolate whoopie pie with traditional marshmallow creme/frosting is also sinful <3 I'd love to get my hands on this book! :<
I’ve always called them gobs, but I’ve also heard “moon pies” used… The traditional chocolate one often has too sweet a filling for me so I tend to go for the pumpkin and cream cheese icing ones when available.
They’re whoopie pies, and pumpkin chocolate chip is the best!
I’m originally from Western PA and have only known them as gobs until I moved to Virginia and EVERYONE here refers to them as whoopie pies…but they’re gobs. I’m simple, I like chocolate with the fattening vanilla filling. However, this s’mores version looks wonderful…
I’ve called them gobs, whoopie pies, and yum yums – I love the almond cake with raspberry filling flavor at Bethel Bakery. Smores and tiramisu whoopie pies sound heavenly.
I call them whoopie pies and my favorite so far is red velvet. I made them in the shape of hearts for Valentines Day but you can bet I will definitely be making these this weekend. I love Smores anything!
Yay I just bought graham flour the other day to make crackers! I’m sure I’ll have extra to make something like this.
I’d call them whoopie pies. And I can’t remember having them…
I’ve never heard the term “gobs” before, so I know them as whoopie pies. And honestly, I don’t think I’ve ever eaten one!!! *gasp*
I first knew these as ‘gobs’ because I lived in northeast Ohio and I had friends who grew up in Pennsylvania making ‘gobs’. I was given her family recipe for gobs and I’ve treasured it ever since. I can’t wait to try your S’mores GOBS! They look amazing.
Whoopie pies! I don’t know that I’ve had a tried and true version, but the ones that have chocolate chip cookies on the outside and a yummy icing-like filling on the inside are pretty darn good!
I’ve always known them as whoopie pies, but I don’t think I’ve ever had one before! I’m from the South, so maybe it’s a northern thing? But Marshmallow fluff sandwiched between anything sounds pretty good to me. Think you could work in some peanut butter and banana for a fluffer-nutter whoopie pie?
They are definitely gobs! (I’m from Western PA.) I last made them in December for a cookie exchange. I will try this recipe next!
Oh my! I don’t know what to call it, but it looks delicious!
To me, they’re whoopie pies, and until recently I’d only ever had the traditional chocolate with vanilla cream filling. Recently I had a pumpkin one that was pretty tasty. Great post, as always I can’t wait to try these s’more ones!
Whoopie Pie and chocolate! I still remember the first time I got one!
It is without a doubt a Whoopie Pie. I like Banana nut best, but I will eat any of them YUMO!!!!!
Whoopie pies! I’ve never made them before, have almost forgotten about them-until now!!!Thanks so much.
I’ve never heard of gobs before, but I love whoopie pies! My favorite flavor is chocolate, of course.
I made these a few weeks ago and OMG so amazing! http://telly21182.blogspot.com/2010/05/smores-whoopie-pies.html
Now I want to make them again after seeing how pretty yours are!
I guess I should enter as well – I’d say it’s definitely a Whoopie Pie and my favorite flavor is without a doubt the Smores one. I love ANYTHING smores!
Definitely whoopie pies! The best one I ever had was a pumpkin flavored outside with a cream cheese filling. Yummy!
Whoopie Pies! And I’ll take any flavor on the outside, as long as the filling is that super-sweet white frosting :)
Whoopie Pie’s ! I live in Maryland and never heard them called gobs before. These look fantastic! I love Whoopie Pie’s.
In PA dutch country, they’re whoopie pies. and it’s the chocolate cake with the shortening filling. So amazing.
I would say Whoopie Pies! I’ve actually never had one! I’m putting them on my list to try now~!
whoopie pies. i’ve never tried them before cause they remind me of oatmeal creme pies which i despise. but really, they are probably so much better. so i should try them.
Gobs or Whoopie! Well, I’ve only heard of them referred to as whoopie pies, but I like “Gobs”…How about “Gobs of Whoopie” You could start a contest on creating the most unique “Gobs of Whoopie” among readers. As I’ve only tried the chocolate, I’m anxious to try some other flavors…grandchildren, get ready for a treat!
Oh, they’re ~definitely~ whoopie pies! I grew up in Maine, and these were a local favorite. I’m most fond of the “standard” flavors of chocolate filled with creamy goodness, but I’m really interested in trying a pumpkin spice/cream cheese filling combo one of these days.
kentuckycooking[at]gmail[dot]com
Oh MY! These look INCREDIBLE!!!
Well, I’d have to say Whoopie Pie. Being from Texas, I’d barely even heard of Whoopie Pies and this is my first time hearing of gobs! :)
I have never heard of them referred to as gabs so for me, it’s pies all the way. My absolute FAV flavor has got to be Pumpkin Cakes with Cream Cheese Filling…YUM. These smores ones look like they could come in second though :)
They’re whoopie pies and they look delicious!
They are whoopie pies but growing up we didn’t have them. Now, being an adult, I have only had chocolate with white creme filling which I made. Loved them!
We called them Globs. They were the classic chocolate but we used the same whipped filling that we used in our Lady Locks. I never thought of using a differnt filling. I’m glad I read the article in the PG. So I vote for Gobs.
I have followed your blog for awhile now because I too am a fellow(former) Pittsburgh gal and love all things Pittsburgh. Ironically enough I was there for the 4th of July holiday and picked up some gobs for my hubby. He had never been exposed to their delicousness and when I brought them to him he exclaimed “OH WHOOPIE PIES” haha I love the traditional chocolate ones but my hubby prefers the blonde version. No matter how long I am away from Pittsburgh they will always be gobs!
My family has always called them whoopee pies and my favorite is chocolate!
I’ve always known them as Whoopie Pies! My grandma used to make the black and white ones! Delish!
Whoopie Pies. I’ve only ever had the original, but these s’mores ones look verrrry interesting. And Marshmallow Fluff??? Is this a brand name? All I’ve ever seen is Kraft’s brand…
Having been born and raised in Northern Indiana, these are most definitely known around here as Whoopie Pies! The Amish have a thing about making them…mostly chocolate though. Give me a Pumpkin Cream Cheese Whoopie Pie and no one gets hurt!
Since it is a GOB of icing between two pieces of cake, I’ll go with Gob. Whoopee has a different connotation to me. ;) I like pumpkin with cream cheese. Thanks for the great give away.
Definitely whoopie pies! I just had one for the first time ever last week…red velvet with the most delicious cream cheese center. Yum!
I’ve never heard the term “gob” before, so I’m going to go with Whoopie Pie. And I’ve only ever had store bought whoopie pies, but these are defintely going to the top of my must-try list. :)
I’ve only heard of them as whoopie pies. I’ve never tried one either. Guess I should get on that, eh?
i have been told by more than one professional baker that my whoopee pies (never heard them called gobs before) are the best out there. I just returned from Amish country, their pies are “wet” mine are dry….here is my recipe that I am happy to share. So many people won’t share their recipes
Whoopee Pies
–
For the cake part, mix the following together
1 cup sugar
2 cup flour
1 tea. baking soda
1 tea. baking powder
5 table. cocoa
1/2 cup crisco
2 egg yolks
1 cup milk
1/2 tea vanilla
using the smaller cookie scooper (about 1 tablespoon) put on ungreased cookie sheet (i use a slipmat) for 10-12, should be firm to touch when done.
For the cream party, mix the following together
1/4 soften butter
1/2 cup crisco
3/4 cup confectionary sugar
2 tea. vanilla
1 1/2 cup marshmallow fluff
mix together and beat until fluffy. Spoon out cream on one pie and top
with a matching pie. Makes about 20 pies, recipe can easily be doubled
Thanks for the recipe. I so want to make these again – whoopie pies that is. I made a Pumpkin version a year or so ago and loved them. Thanks for sharing.
These are whoopee pies, or as they are known in my house “wookie pies” my daughters boyfriend miss heard her and didn’t know what a wookie pie was…
Bring a former New Englander, I’m a traditional chocolate an white cream girl…..but every now and then…..molasses or pumpkin is quite yummy!
I call it a whoopie Pie. I think these s’mores ones look awsome. I have not had a lot of whoopie Pies but I do like moon pies.
Gobs all the way! We made gobs as children ONLY when my aunt came over. Couldn’t wait for those weekends – I’ve had traditional, strawberry, lemon, and a pretty interesting vanilla with apple filling.
I would call it a Whoopie Pie, kind of a fun name I think. I’ve never had them but they look delish!
I know them as whoopie pies, and the best one I’ve had was a pumpkin one at our fair last year. But these s’mores ones look even better!
whoopie pie for sure. My favorite is a vanilla with strawberry filling!
A whoopie pie! Man, I’d love to have this book. During the fall I was obsessed with making pumpkin ones with maple filling. Yum!
Seeing as how I’ve never heard of a gob before…I’m going to have to go with whoopie pie. And I’m a red velvet girl all the way.
Although your smores version could convert me…
I’ve never had one, but I’ve always wanted to try the red velvet ones. I’ve going to have to break down and make some for myself.
It’s a GOB! I grew up eating gobs from a small bakery in Latrobe, PA called The Pie Shop (which, by the way, also makes the BEST cinnamon rolls). I believe the bakery is now called Armel’s, but they still make the greatest, classic gobs. In the fall you can also purchase pumpkin gobs with cream cheese filling. YUM!
Great cookbook idea and recipes!
Thanks!
I’ve never really had one, but I think they are whoopie pies. Maybe this recipe will be my first and favorite :)
They are whoopie pies. I should say my favorite is my grandmother’s recipe for chocolate with vanilla cream filling that everyone raves about BUT, I just recently made a lemon one that was to die for! So I’ll have to say lemon.
Definitely whoopie pie! I love just plain ol’ chocolate with vanilla cream filling.
I’ve only heard them called whoopie pies. I’ve only tried red velvet with a cream cheese icing filling but they were delicious.
Whoopie pies! I’ve only ever had the chocolate ones. This book looks great!
They are Gobs! Never Whoopie Pies. The family favorite is chocolate batter with a white, creamy filling made from canned milk, vanilla and sugar. I’ve tried lots of varieties from farm markets in the Lancaster, PA area, but they’re often filled with a frosting that is just too sweet and not creamy enough. We make them for a cookie tray at Christmas every year. yum
I have never heard them referred to as anything other than Whoopie Pies!
I’ve heard of whoopie pies, but never gobs, but I don’t think I’ve ever actually had either. These s’mores whoopie pies looks delicious!
Although they are Whoopie Pies to me, I have heard of “Gobs” before. My favorite is the traditional chocolate with the vanilla filling, but I can’t wait to try out this smore recipe!
The first time I had a whoopie pie was in February. I was at Baked in Brooklyn, and I think I ate the most amazing one ever – banana with peanut butter filling.
I hate the word “gob” so they’re definitely whoopie pies! :)
I’ve never heard of a gob before…they’re whoopie pies! My favorite is the classic chocolate with white filling. Pumpkin with cream cheese filling are good, too!
To me I think it depends…softer, gooey cookies would be called gobs, think pumpkin ‘gobs’ and whoopie pies are more of a firmer set cookie, perhaps even crunchy, think oatmeal cream ‘whoopie’ pies. no matter the name, they are all delish in their own way!
Even though I’m from Pittsburgh, I spent too much time eating these in Philly from the Amish baked good stand in the Reading Terminal, so they are whoopie pies. I like the classic chocolate, but pumpkin whoopie pies rock, too.
In southwest PA, they are now and have always been GOBS. I’m 52 and never heard of them being called whoopie pies until about a year ago. I’m a traditionalist and I prefer the original dark rich chocolate with a crisco based filling. So rich, so creamy, so decadent. You can’t go wrong with the original.
They’re whoopie pies. I’ve had them in chocolate and red velvet – both with white fluffy filling.
I only ever knew them as Whoopie Pies. When i go shopping today I am picking up necessary ingredients to try the smore whoopies. They look like they’re worth turning on the oven in the heat.
I know them as whoopie pies and the flavor has to be chocolate with the white fluff/icing inside.
They are definitely gobs, and chocolate is my favorite. I grew up in Western PA., and my mom (who is an excellent baker), made them for us from scratch. The best!
Woopie Pies in my world. Can’t wait to try them – isn’t marshmallow creme a food group?
They are whoppie pies here in Maine! I love them! Just made some molasses ones last week actually!
Whoopie pies to me, but Gobs to my hubby! My favorite is most definitely pumpkin with a cream cheese filling – YUM!
It’s a whoopie pie! And although I’ve never tried one before, I think I would like a chocolate and peanut butter one!
They are whoopie pies and I adore the red velvet pies with the cream cheese centers; however, I have a feeling these s’mores whoopie pies are going to give them a run for their money!
They are whoopie pies to me, but everyone seems to laugh when I say the name! I am a chocolate/peanut butter lover so my favorite whoopie pie would have to be Peanut Butter whoopie pies…chocolate cookies sandwiched between a rich peanut butter filling!!
Definitely Whoopie Pies, and gotta go with favorite flavor being the traditional chocolate with marshmellow cream filling!!
Whoopie pies here too… but never had one – but would oh so love to try one now!!
They’re neither whoopie pies nor gobs to me, but moon pies :) Mom is from NC, Daddy was from TX, and that’s what they call them in the south (though as Helen pointed out, they are moon pies turned inside out).
Definitely gobs since I’m a Pittsburgher. My mother used to make
delicious oatmeal gobs with a vanilla filling. I haven’t thought about them
in ages until I read the article in the Post Gazette this morning. :)
They’re Whoopie Pies. And the original chocolate is the best – made from scratch without the canned marshmallow fluff nonesense. And….they’re best in Holmes County, Ohio! :-)
Definitely whoopie pies. I love red velvets.
They’re definitely Southern…. Moon Pies originated in Chattanoogo,TN and are Whoopie Pies turned inside out! LOL! Moon Pies are chocolate coated – what more could you ask for??? CHOCOLATE! Yummmm!
we call them whoopie pies here. They are a hugely popular treat in No. ME. I only like the ones with cream cheese frosting. My favorite is the pumpkin chocolate chip whoopie pie with cc frosting that a co-worker makes. mmmmmmmm
Hi!
I would call them whoopie pies because that name is so cute!
I would looove to win that book! I’ve just now, 5 minutes before reading your post, been looking at it on Amazon! It’s meant to be. I want to try all the lovely looking recipes and try whoopie pies or gobs because I’ve never had one in my whole life.
Petra
I haven’t heard about gobs before, so whoopie pies it is :) I have only tried store bought, the usual, vanilla/chocolate flavour and like them :) Maybe I’ll try to make them myself these days ;)
I know them as Whoopie Pies but don’t think I’ve ever tried them before. Are they as delicious as they look???
Hmm… where I come from a “gob” is a slang term for mouth so I think I’d prefer to know them as whoopie pies to be honest!
I’ve never tried them (you don’t really see them here), but have wanted to for a while so I think I’m going to have to give these a go! And maybe the tiramisu ones, they sound awesome!
Thanks!
Becka xx
Well, I’d say they are whoopie pies, just because I like how funny it sounds. :)
Since I’m from Brazil, I have never had/heard of a whoopie pie before, but now I’m definitely going to make those! They really look delicious, you can’t go wrong with chocolate and marshmallow.
Hi, Michelle. This is definitely a whoopie pie (thank you, though, for teaching us all about “gobs”). I always have eaten and enjoyed the chocolate-fluffy-white-fillled whoopie pies. However, the smores version looks awfully tempting….
Great post and fun giveaway!
Thanks,
Dan
They are whoppie pies to me. I haven’t tried too many of them, but I”ve seen them popping up everywhere. I love just the original.
They’re whoopie pies! I’ve only ever had the traditional devils food variety but i have a recipe somewhere for a chocolate gob with cherry filling and these smores ones beg a try as well YUM!
They’re whoopie pies! I have never tried them though! Shame on me.
Here in The Netherlands I don’t think we have a special name for these or any kind of “double cookies”. I just know these cookies from the food blog photo’s I’ve seen lately and they all refer to them as Whoopie Pies. The word “gob” means something entirely different to me (something entirely unappetizing!)
I’ve never had these whoopie pies before, so couldn’t tell you my favorite flavour. Is there one basic or “best” flavour you’d recommend for my first taster?
I’m assuming they’re whoopie pies since I’ve never heard of gobs before :) The only one I’ve ever tasted was red velvet with a cream cheese frosting and it was sooo good! I’d love to start making them myself.
They’re whoopie pies. I’ve only had 1 kind before: lemon. So by default it wins as my favourite but I’d love to try more.
They are Whoopie Pies as I know them. And I’ve only had the store bought and homemade chocolate with white frosting middle. YUM!