Baked French Toast Casserole with Praline Topping
This French toast casserole is wonderfully decadent, making it perfect for holidays or overnight guests!
There is perhaps no better occasion for an off-the-charts, blowout breakfast feast than Christmas morning. You’ve spent weeks decorating, making lists, buying gifts and wrapping. And in a flash, much like the letdown after waiting an hour in line to ride a 2-minute roller coaster, it’s over. The gifts have been opened and there is wrapping paper strewn about all over the floor. How fabulous to then meander into the kitchen and be able to sit down to a decadent, celebratory breakfast that took almost zero time in the morning? Ahh, the beauty of the make-ahead breakfast casserole. This one is truly extra-special!
This French toast casserole is the epitome of indulgent, and I absolutely love it. Embrace it – Christmas only comes once a year!
You can assemble the casserole the day before, and the next morning all you need to do is top it with the praline topping (which takes less than 10 minutes to make) and then pop it into the oven. If you get your timing right, you can get it into the oven and by the time you’re done opening presents, it will be ready and you can sit down to a beautiful, hot breakfast.
Do you have any Christmas breakfast traditions at your house?
One year ago: Chocolate-Covered Potato Chips
Two years ago: Italian Sesame Seed Cookies (Giuggliulena)
Five years ago: Date, Coconut & Walnut Truffles
Baked French Toast Casserole with Praline Topping
This French toast casserole is wonderfully decadent, making it perfect for holidays or overnight guests!
Ingredients:
- 1 loaf French bread (13 to 16 ounces)
- 8 eggs
- 2 cups half-and-half
- 1 cup milk
- 2 tablespoons granulated sugar
- 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
- ¼ teaspoon ground cinnamon
- ¼ teaspoon ground nutmeg
- Dash of salt
For the Praline Topping:
- 1 cup unsalted butter, at room temperature
- 1 cup light brown sugar
- 1 cup chopped pecans
- 2 tablespoons light corn syrup
- ½ teaspoon ground cinnamon
- ½ teaspoon ground nutmeg
- Pinch of salt
Directions:
- Generously butter a 9×13-inch baking dish.
- Slice the French bread into 20 one-inch-thick slices. Arrange the slices in the baking dish in two rows, overlapping the slices.
- In a large bowl, combine the eggs, half-and-half, milk, sugar, vanilla, cinnamon, nutmeg and salt with a whisk until blended but not too bubbly. Pour the mixture over the bread slices, making sure all are covered evenly with the milk-egg mixture. Spoon some of the mixture in between the slices. Cover with foil and refrigerate overnight.
- The next day, preheat the oven to 350 degrees F.
- Make the Praline Topping: Combine all ingredients in a medium bowl and blend well, using a pastry blended or your fingertips.
- Spread the praline topping evenly over the bread and bake for 40 minutes, until puffed and lightly golden. Serve with maple syrup.
Did you make this recipe?
Leave a review below, then snap a picture and tag @thebrowneyedbaker on Instagram so I can see it!
(Recipe adapted from Paula Deen)
All images and text ©
This recipe was originally published on December 22, 2011.
This is delicious looking! I am in love with french toast, so any excuse to change it up brightens my day!!…for realz.
Oh my goodness, this looks incredible. I may eat the whole pan if I make this. And I think I’m okay with that 😛 SO delicious looking!
Oooo! Christmas morning here we come!
I have to add that I found your post for breakfast sausage, egg & cheese casserole today. Looks like I am making two prepare ahead yummies for Christmas this year!
Thanks for all your hard work!
Yummmm. I love French Toast casserole. I made one last weekend, but just with a crumb topping. I wish I’d had the recipe for the praline topping then! It looks awesome!
This sounds sooo good….a great way to start off the day. Would for sure need to have seconds.
This sweet casserole is making me drool – I want this on christmas, eve, morn and on new years too!
I have been SO wanting to make a baked french toast! This recipe looks like the perfect start 🙂
I made this recently and it’s one of the BEST things ever. EVER! 🙂
Hi everyone, it looks so yummy, I have a question though, I prefer crunchy French toast, is this mushy toast or does it bake crunchy? Thanks! Happy Holidays!
Hi JoAnn, The top is nice and crunchy; the bottom is softer. I hope that helps!
this sounds delish! cannot wait to try!
have a great day!!!
My great-grandfather owned a bakery and it would not be Christmas without his stollen. It’s not really Christmas for me until they come out of the oven!
Holy Cow! For me that praline topping is the keeper and the fact that you bake it.
I may switch the half and half out with the eggnog. Thank you for sharing this find.
Our tradition for Christmas breakfast is walnut cinnamon rolls and grapefruits.
As we age, the grapefruit has been replaced with an egg breakfast casserole due to (Lipitor) drug interactions.
This is exactly what Christmas morning should taste like!
This is beautiful and would certainly give me that boost of energy to get through Christmas Day!
Mmmm. I make this every year for Christmas morning! So easy!
I love baked french toast, it’s so nice for when you have company you don’t have to stand at the stove the whole time. This recipe looks so wonderful!
Ooohhh, that looks good! One of my favorite Christmas traditions as a kid was making waffles dying the batter red and green. We had a waffle iron, but for some reason Christmas morning was about the only time we used it.
My husband’s aunt made something very similar to this for Easter and it was soooo good. I just emailed her to ask if she will be making it for Christmas Brunch also!
This sounds so amazing! I wish I had a slice right now! How do you do it? How do you make all of these wonderful goodies and not get as big as a house? I have such a hard time! I lick the batter, eat the dough, eat the baked good, scoop up some chips, I can’t stop! I’d eat my computer if I knew I could get one taste of your baked french toast! Do you eat everything you make?
Hi Jennifer, I do eat some of everything I make, but not every last bite. I do a lot of sharing with family, my boyfriend, many times my mom will ask to take things to work for her coworkers, etc. Some things I will freeze for easy desserts later. I basically have an “everything in moderation” approach to eating, and don’t really overdo it on any one thing.
Delicious! The bread looks so puffy and pleasant. This would make for a wonderful breakfast with some genuine maple syrup.
I always make an apple french toast casserole and a shrimp and grits casserole for Christmas morning. You have inspired me to change up my french toast casserole. Thanks!
If you want to make the shrimp and grits, this is the recipe I use, but this has far too much salt for me. I use the sodium free chicken broth instead. Also, if you like heat skip all the salt and pepper altogether and use the same portions of Tony Chachere’s Creole Seasoning or drop in a couple of dashes of Tabasco sauce. It’s so good. Double the recipe, everyone will eat seconds or thirds. http://www.myrecipes.com/recipe/cheesy-shrimp-and-grits-casserole-10000000522445/
OMG this looks SO good!! We have some sort of french toast every yr for Christmas breakfast, must just have to try this one out this yr. Yum!
We usually do some simple, classic monkey bread for Christmas morning, but I’m sensing a change in holiday tradition this year! YUM!
Monkey bread it is for us as well. We alsways have done the ‘simple’ version with the dough coming from Pilsbury. My husband and I decided to try it from scratch one year and didn’t end up being able to eat it until noon. The dough needs to rise multiple times which we didn’t really factor in. So now it’s back to Pilsbury.
As always… beautiful job, Michelle!
xo
http://allykayler.blogspot.com
Oh my goodness! This looks divine! I might have to add this to our Traditions list! 🙂
ahhhh I LOVE french toast! This looks amazing!
Bookmarking this right now! I am so making this for Christmas morning! Sounds so delicious!!
We are serious munchers in my house – seems we never really do the same thing twice, but you can bet there will always be some scones floating around!
We have Orange Rolls on Christmas morning. When I was a kid they came out of a can, then I discovered Rhodes made them, now I make my own. But this casserole sounds good for New Year’s Day morning!!
This sounds great! I usually make egg nog french toast for xmas morning breakfast, but a make ahead casserole sounds like a wonderful idea! I think I’ll try this and use egg nog instead of half and half to see if it mixes the best of our usual tradition with your amazing recipe. Thanks!
I make this for Christmas morning every year. Try it with Challah Bread- it’s really good! ♥
Yum! We normally have cinnamon rolls for breakfast on Christmas morning, but I might have to make this instead!
I have made this French Toast recipe twice.
Both times everyone absolutely loved it – while it is very rich, it is a great choice for a special breakfast/brunch. That it can be made the night before is also a real positive.
I’ve made this recipe several times, and I LOVE it! Though on Christmas morning, my mom always makes an egg and cheese casserole with apple muffins.
This looks absolutely delicious! Our breakfast tradition at our house is Eggs Benedict! It’s our favorite – and it’s a lovely thing to have when we wake up….then nothing until dinner!
Oh my, anything with a praline topping is devoured by me in seconds! Looks fantastic!
This looks absolutely amazing..will definitely try on Christmas morning!!!
Getting ready to make this right now for Christmas Eve morning. Thank you for the inspiration, encouragement, and information!
Planning to serve this as our Christmas morning dish! 🙂 My husband can’t wait to eat it! Thanks for the idea!
i love french toast casserole and it’s a must around Christmas in our house. Yours looks amazing!
Merry Christmas!
Put this in the oven when present opening was well underway Christmas morning. A REALLY BIG HIT and the perfect way to not miss any of the fun. I’m to the point where I’m in need of a food blog intervention, but yours is a very consistent source of great ideas. Thanks.
I made this same recipe that I found from Paula Deen but instead of the half & half I used eggnog & it was absolutely amazing & everybody loved it!
My stomach just demanded this, but the thought of getting out of my sweatpants and going outside into the cold to the grocery store is not appealing. But this casserole oh how it is very much so appealing!
This looks so much better than stand-over-the-frying-pan French Toast…I think I’ll be trying this for New Years brunch!
I made this recipe for Christmas this year, and my family LOVED it! They’ll ask for it again, I’m sure!!
this is an awesome recipe. i’m so gonna try it! btw, what can i use as a substitute for half and half and corn syrup? (if there’re any)
Hi Jenn, For the half & half you can substitute half whole milk and half cream. For the corn syrup I think you could probably eliminate it and still be okay.
I made this for Christmas eve brunch for my family- it was sooooo amazingly good! Even some of our pickier family members were raving about it. I unfortunately used a baking dish that was just a tad to short and some of the liquid bubbled over…. which made for a smokey Christmas eve mess, but really is it Christmas without a smokey kitchen? 🙂 Thank you so much for sharing this one and if anyone is considering making this – be smarter than me and use the proper pan. 🙂
Ps: Because my husband is danish he insisted that we serve it with fresh whipped cream – which beyond the unnecessary calories was AMAZING! 🙂
Do you think this recipe would work with egg bread instead? It’s all I have in my kitchen right now.
Yes, absolutely!
Oh I love French Toasts and this just takes it to another level altogether!Bookmarked!
Hello! I was wondering, Does the amount of time this soaks over night need to be a certain amount? I wont be able to make this until late at night, after 11pm, to be prepared for early the next day (6-7am). Should I prepare it earlier in the afternoon or will it even matter? This recipe is great I can’t wait to try it! thanks!
Hi Ellen, You will be just fine preparing it at 11pm and baking it up early the next morning. I think about 5-6 hours is a good minimum soak time.
Hi Michelle! Instead of half and half, do you think I could use buttermilk? That’s all I have in my fridge right now… Unless I use a French vanilla creamer! Haha! Thanks!!
Hi Stephanie, I definitely would not use buttermilk here. It will really alter the flavor of the dish (buttermilk has so much tang), and it has a much, much thicker consistency than half-and-half.
OMG! You are a goddess!!!! Thank you, thank you, thank you for this recipe!!! I went away with 5 girlfriends that I’ve known since junior high….we are now in our mid-40’s, so that’s a long time ago! Anyway, I signed up to be in charge of breakfast… I made this casserole and a savory one, so all flavor bases were covered. This was such a hit! We had enough of both casseroles for breakfast the 2nd morning….and everyone was very excited about that. I passed the recipe along and can’t wait for the next time to make it!!!
P.S. I did feel a bit like Paula Deen with the butter though, but it was SO worth it!!!
I made this for a ladies brunch last weekend and served it with Poinsettias (champagne and cranberry juice). They were both a big hit! Thanks for the great rec. I agree the butter was a bit much. I had a pool of butter on the top of mine– I think you might easily cut 1/4 to 1/2 the butter in the topping.
I made this for our Christmas morning breakfast and it came out great. My husband and our 3 year old really enjoyed it. It’s very sweet! I love sweet things but for some reason, after we added the syrup it was a bit much for me so early in the morning. lol I will most likely make this one again for another special occasion or holiday. I may consider leaving out the praline topping on half of the bake and see if I enjoy it more that way.. I figure it’s worth a shot.
Hi Michelle, this sounds awesome! Unfortunately my wife has an aversion to soggy bread! Does it bake long enough to dry the bread, or does it still come out a bit soppy?
Thanks a bunch for all the great food ideas 🙂
Rob
Hi Rob, This isn’t soggy, but the bread doesn’t dry out. It has the consistency of custard.
Really good!!! Made for brunch today and the pan was cleaned and guests were caught scraping the sides and bottom for more. I used Challah bread that was slightly dry and I think it held together well. Also used ground pecans so it was like a paste I spread on the top. Very successful recipe.
Is there anything you can replace the nuts with? I’m serving this to an allergy aware crowd and I don’t want to seem insensitive.
Hi Julie, I would just omit them, unless you want to use something liked dried fruit.
As I was about to finish typing this into my iPad recipe app I realized it was the same one as Paula Deene and then it was mentioned at the bottom of recipe. I have made this previously with no problem cutting the eggs to 5 or 6 and the butter in half in the ingredients…just wanted you all to know that…
This looks amazing!!!
Kari
http://www.sweetteasweetie.com
This sounds amazing!
Absolutely no offense intended here, Michelle, but if you want snow for Christmas, then I’d like to suggest that you might like to take a trip to someplace snowy 🙂 🙂 Not that I’m enjoying all of the rain here in the Pittsburgh area, mind you, but at least we don’t have to shovel it. Wishing you and yours a very Merry Christmas and a Happy & Healthy New Year, and thanks for all of the great recipes that you have given to us all this year, as well as all of the cute pictures of Joseph!!!
A casserole–sure beats standing over a stove skillet in hand.
You are wanting snow and here in Texas we do not. At least not until Christmas is over. Joseph looks so cute with Santa.
My husbands best friend from Viet Nam lived near Pittsburgh. He had a new Cadillac and kept it in garage all winter. Lost him about 3 years ago.
My daughters boss is from Boston and has already gone home for the rest of the year.
Hi,
Looks amazing! I have a question though, does this toast bake up crispy and crunchy, or is it mushy? I don’t care for mush, but it looks awesome and like it might be firm in texture. Thanks! Merry Christmas 2015!
I absolutely LOVE this recipe!! (I love all your recipes and check your blog daily!) This particular recipe has become part of my husband and I’s Christmas tradition for the past 3 years. We have it every Christmas morning and plan to every year. Thanks for helping us start our own family traditions!! I hope you had a wonderful Christmas this year!
We had your French Toast with Praline Topping for breakfast Christmas morning. Everyone loved it! Because it was Christmas, I substituted one cup of eggnog for one of the cups of milk. Thank you for a great recipe!
This recipe turned out so well! I was delicious! My husband said it was the best French Toast he had ever had! I put the topping on the night before and it baked up fine the next morning. (I wanted to streamline things for Christmas morning! ?) I love your site and your recipes! Thank you! Happy New Year!
Hi! I decided to make this for my inlaws tomorrow but came across an issue with the French bread. A standard 16oz loaf, doesn’t cut into 20 one inch slices, I was able get about 14. Are you sure it’s not French baguettes instead of loaf?
Also, because there wasn’t 20 slices, it was difficult to layer and still fill the entire pan. Fingers crossed it turns out!!
Hi Anisa, Yes, positive it wasn’t a baguette; I think it should still be fine!
Who needs to wait for Christmas? I made this last weekend for a houseful of guests. There was none left!! It is the perfect dish for entertaining as it can be made the night before.