Inside: All of the details you need to make the absolute BEST graham cracker crust! Many people turn to the beloved graham cracker crust when looking for an alternative or shortcut to traditional pie crust, but so many fall short. This is seriously the ONLY recipe you will ever need. It tastes amazing and comes out perfectly every single time, PLUS you can use it for no-bake pies or pies where the crust needs to be baked.
You want to make a super-fast no-bake pie for that summer cookout you’re heading to tomorrow, so you Google a graham cracker crust recipe.
Or maybe you just use the crust recipe that comes with the pie recipe.
It’s fiiiiiine, but wouldn’t you totally love a graham cracker crust recipe that tastes AMAZING, that you would totally eat by the spoonful, and sets up perfectly, never crumbling, each and every time? One that you could insert into any pie recipe you wanted to make, ever? And never need to Google another crust recipe again?
I’ve got you covered.
What Makes This Graham Cracker Crust the Best?
I know, graham cracker crusts seem so elementary, but if you’ve ever lifted a slice of pie out of the pan and had the crust break and crumble all over the plate (mortifying if you’re serving to company and just plain annoying otherwise!), then you KNOW how important a good crust is! Let’s discuss…
Perfectly Moist – I’ve had the (dis)pleasure of making graham cracker crusts that both crumble as described above, and that leak liquid because there is too much butter. This recipe strikes the perfect balance to create a crust that holds together beautifully and never crumbles.
Flavor! It might not seem important in something like a graham cracker crust, but honestly? I could eat this crust ON ITS OWN. Using brown sugar takes it from boring-basic graham crust to something truly delicious on its own.
Clean Slices Every Time – Quite possibly the most important aspect of any crust recipe. You want super clean slices every single time. Get that crust packed in nice and tight (follow the instructions in the recipe!) and you’ll have perfect pieces of pie from now until infinity.
Only Four Ingredients Needed!
This crust comes together incredibly quickly thanks to needing only four ingredients and a super simple mixing process.
Graham Cracker Crumbs – Of course! You can use whole graham crackers and crush them up or buy a box of ready-made graham cracker crumbs. If crushed them yourself, you could use a food processor and pulse until you get fine crumbs, or put the graham crackers in a zip-top bag and crush them with a mallet, can, or anything pseudo-heavy.
Sugar – We use light brown sugar to keep the crust moist and give it a little more of a browned-butter/toffee flavor.
Butter – This is a smidge more than is used in most crust recipes, but it really helps to bind the crust together and keep it from crumbling apart when it’s sliced. (Want to ratchet this crust up a notch? Use browned butter!)
Salt – Because salt makes EVERYTHING (sweet and savory) taste better!
Mix these four ingredients together for the most amazing crust you ever will meet.
How To Make The Best Graham Cracker Crust
This is super basic, but let’s walk through the steps together!
Start with Graham Cracker Crumbs – If you haven’t purchased pre-made crumbs, then grab your graham crackers and crush them up into fine crumbs, measure out 2 cups, and place them in a medium bowl.
Add the Brown Sugar and Salt – Stir together the graham cracker crumbs with the brown sugar and salt, making sure that there are no lumps of brown sugar left in the bowl.
Stir in the Melted Butter – Drizzle the melted butter over the graham cracker mixture and use a fork to mix everything together, ensuring that it is evenly moistened. Attempt to not eat the entire bowl right now (important step).
Press and Pack the Crust Into a Pan – This is VITAL! Years ago, I heard about the tip to press a graham cracker (or Oreo) crust into the pan using the bottom and sides of a measuring cup and it is a total game-changer. Getting that crust packed in nice and tight means that it holds together beautifully when sliced instead of crumbling all over the place. Seriously, take the extra few minutes to do it! You can use anything – dry measuring cups, a liquid measuring cup, a regular old drinking glass – anything that has a round bottom will do!
Pies Using a Graham Cracker Crust:
Now that you’re armed with the best (and easiest!) graham cracker crust recipe, start adding these pies to your must-make list!